Iowa Abortion Laws: Understanding The Current Landscape

Abortion laws in the US state of Iowa have been subject to much change in the past few years. In 2020, Iowa's Supreme Court held that the due process and equal protection clauses of the Iowa Constitution protect the fundamental right to abortion. However, in 2022, the Court overruled itself, stating that the Iowa Constitution is not the source of a fundamental right to an abortion. This set the stage for further restrictions on abortion access in the state. As of July 2024, Iowa is enforcing a 6-week ban on abortions, with limited exceptions in cases of rape, incest, foetal abnormalities, and when the mother's life is in danger. This ban is expected to force Iowa residents to seek care in neighbouring states that have taken action to maintain or expand abortion access.

Iowa's six-week abortion ban

The Iowa abortion ban includes limited exceptions for cases of rape, incest, foetal abnormalities, or when the mother's life is in danger. Previously, abortion was legal in Iowa up to 20 weeks of pregnancy. The new law is based on the detection of cardiac activity in the foetus or embryo, which typically occurs at around six weeks. However, the exact timing can be approximate, and medical groups have criticised the term "fetal heartbeat" as a mischaracterisation of the electronic impulses that signify early cardiac development.

The six-week ban in Iowa is part of a broader trend of abortion restrictions enacted by several states following the US Supreme Court's decision in 2022 to overturn Roe v. Wade, which had guaranteed the right to abortion before foetal viability, usually between 24 and 28 weeks. As of October 2024, 41 states have abortion bans in effect, with 13 states having a total abortion ban and 28 states banning abortion based on gestational duration. Iowa joins other Midwestern states, including Missouri and South Dakota, in enacting restrictions since Roe's overturn.

The Iowa abortion ban has been criticised by abortion rights advocates, who argue that it will hurt residents, particularly women of reproductive age from marginalised communities. They predict that the law will force people to seek care in neighbouring states that have maintained or expanded abortion access, such as Illinois and Minnesota. Polls show that a majority of Iowans believe abortion should be legal in most or all cases, despite the state's new restrictive law.

The enforcement of the six-week abortion ban in Iowa is expected to be a significant issue in the 2024 general election, with Democrats criticising it as an attack on women's rights and Republicans celebrating it as a victory for the "culture of life". Vice President Kamala Harris, the expected Democratic presidential nominee, has promised to restore reproductive rights and protect abortion access if elected.

Exceptions to the ban

Iowa's abortion law, which prohibits most abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy, includes a few limited exceptions. These exceptions allow for abortion after the detection of cardiac activity in specific circumstances, which is usually around six weeks into the pregnancy.

The first exception is in cases of rape. For abortion to be permitted under this exception, the rape must be reported to law enforcement or a healthcare provider within 45 days. The second exception is for incest, which must be reported within 145 days. A third exception is for fetal abnormality, where the physician must document how they determined the fetus has an abnormality and why it is "incompatible with life."

Additionally, the law provides for an exception in the case of a medical emergency. This includes pregnancy complications that endanger the life of the pregnant woman or situations where "continuation of the pregnancy will create a serious risk of substantial and irreversible impairment of a major bodily function of the pregnant woman."

It is important to note that while these exceptions exist, the law still imposes significant restrictions on abortion access in Iowa, and the specific guidelines for enforcement and disciplinary action are limited.

Iowa's Republican leaders

The Republican-controlled legislature in Iowa approved the six-week abortion ban in 2023, but its implementation was blocked by a lower court after providers argued that it violated Iowans' constitutional rights. However, the ban was later upheld by the Iowa Supreme Court in a 4-3 ruling in June 2024, and it went into effect in July 2024. This ban prohibits abortions after the detection of cardiac activity in a foetus or embryo, which typically occurs around six weeks into a pregnancy. While there are exceptions in cases of rape, incest, foetal abnormalities, and threats to the mother's life, the ban still stands as one of the most restrictive policies in the nation.

Iowa Republicans' efforts to restrict abortion rights did not begin with the six-week ban. In 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, Governor Reynolds issued an executive order attempting to ban abortion care by classifying it as a "non-essential" procedure. This order was contradicted by major medical groups worldwide, who emphasised the essential and time-sensitive nature of abortion care. The Iowa District Court ultimately approved a settlement agreement, allowing essential abortion care to continue.

The state's Republican leaders have also enacted other measures to restrict abortion access. Iowa law requires pregnant people seeking abortions to undergo biased counselling and ultrasounds, and providers who violate the state's abortion restrictions may face civil and criminal penalties. Additionally, Iowa limits public funding for abortion and has targeted regulation of abortion providers (TRAP) laws, which include reporting requirements.

The push for these restrictive abortion laws in Iowa aligns with the broader trend of Republican-led efforts to restrict abortion access across the United States. Since the overturning of Roe v. Wade, many state legislatures, including Iowa, have created new abortion restrictions or begun enforcing existing ones. These actions have significantly impacted individuals, especially those from marginalised communities, facing systemic racism, and other forms of oppression.

The impact on neighbouring states

Iowa's abortion ban is expected to have a significant impact on neighbouring states, particularly those that have taken action to protect or expand abortion access, such as Illinois and Minnesota. With the enforcement of the abortion ban in Iowa, residents seeking abortion care will likely travel to these adjacent Democrat-led states, increasing demand and putting pressure on providers in these states.

Illinois Governor JB Pritzker has expressed support for Iowans seeking reproductive freedom and has welcomed them to Illinois for the care they need. Similarly, Minnesota Governor Tim Walz has assured that reproductive freedom will remain protected in his state. The impact of the Iowa abortion ban on neighbouring states highlights the uneven access to abortion care across the country, with residents in states with restrictive abortion laws forced to travel to access care.

The influx of patients from Iowa is expected to strain the resources of abortion providers in neighbouring states. To prepare for this increase in demand, Planned Parenthood in the region has been making investments, such as remodelling its centre in Omaha, Nebraska, and offering medication abortion services in Mankato, Minnesota. These efforts aim to ensure that residents of Iowa and neighbouring states have access to safe and legal abortion care, despite the restrictive laws in their home state.

The impact of Iowa's abortion ban on neighbouring states also extends to the political landscape. The issue of abortion rights is expected to be a key focus during the 2024 election, with Democrats criticising the ban as an attack on women's rights and Republicans celebrating it as a victory for the "culture of life". The contrasting responses from neighbouring state governors, such as Illinois and Minnesota, also highlight the political divide on this issue, with blue states affirming their commitment to protecting abortion access.

Furthermore, the impact of Iowa's abortion ban on neighbouring states is likely to be felt beyond the immediate region. With Iowa joining a growing list of Midwestern states, including Missouri and South Dakota, that have enacted restrictions, the geographic accessibility of abortion care in the Midwest is significantly reduced. This may result in residents travelling greater distances to access care, further exacerbating the strain on providers in states that have maintained or expanded abortion access.

The Supreme Court's role

In 2022, the Iowa Supreme Court issued a ruling stating that there was no constitutional right to abortion in the state. This decision was a pivotal moment, as it aligned with the U.S. Supreme Court's move to overturn Roe v. Wade in the same year. The absence of a constitutional right to abortion in Iowa set the stage for further restrictions and legislative action on abortion.

Following this ruling, the Iowa state legislature, with exclusive Republican support, passed a restrictive abortion law during a one-day special session in July 2023. This law, known as the "fetal heartbeat" law, bans abortion after the detection of cardiac activity, which typically occurs around six weeks into a pregnancy. This timeframe is significant because many women do not know they are pregnant at this early stage. The law includes limited exceptions for cases of rape, incest, fetal abnormality, or when the mother's life is in danger.

The Iowa Supreme Court's role was again crucial when it upheld the constitutionality of this restrictive abortion law. In a 4-3 ruling, the court decided that the law did not violate the state constitution and instructed the lower court to dissolve the temporary block on the law. This decision allowed the law to go into effect, making Iowa one of several states with restrictive abortion laws.

The Iowa Supreme Court's rulings have had a significant impact on abortion access in the state. By upholding the restrictive abortion law, the court has effectively limited abortion access for many women in Iowa, shifting the state's stance on reproductive health. The court's decisions have been celebrated by abortion opponents and criticized by abortion rights advocates, highlighting the divisive nature of the issue.

Frequently asked questions