Abortion Laws In Poland: Strict And Controversial

Poland's abortion laws are among the most restrictive in Europe. Abortion is illegal except in cases where the pregnancy is a result of a criminal act or when the woman's life or health is in danger. Even in these limited cases, accessing a legal abortion is extremely difficult, and many women are forced to seek unsafe and illegal abortions or travel abroad for medical care. In recent years, there have been efforts to liberalise abortion laws in Poland, but these have been met with strong opposition from conservative groups and politicians.

Abortion laws in Poland are restrictive

Abortion is only permitted in Poland if the mother's health is at risk, there is a foetal abnormality, or the pregnancy is the result of a criminal act, such as rape or incest. Even in these limited cases, accessing a legal abortion is extremely difficult, and in some cases, impossible. This has resulted in women being denied critical, life-saving care, and some have died in Polish hospitals as a result.

The restrictive nature of Poland's abortion laws means that many women are forced to endure unwanted pregnancies, seek unsafe and illegal abortions, or travel abroad for medical care. This places a huge personal and financial burden on women, and can cause severe physical and mental suffering, which may amount to cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment.

The Polish government has been accused of targeting people for alleged abortion-related activities, creating a climate of fear and heightening risks for women and girls. There have been several cases of women being subjected to intense scrutiny and invasive searches by the police after seeking urgent healthcare for miscarriages or legal medication abortions. Doctors have also been targeted and had their practices raided by the authorities.

In recent years, there have been mass protests in Poland against the restrictive abortion laws, with thousands of people demonstrating in support of abortion rights and calling for legal reform. Despite this, Polish lawmakers continue to debate the legislation, with conservative politicians holding key political positions and the power to block change.

Women's health and bodily autonomy are negatively impacted by Poland's abortion laws

Poland's abortion laws have a detrimental impact on women's health and bodily autonomy. The country's abortion laws are among the most restrictive in Europe, and have been denounced by the United Nations (UN) for causing severe human rights violations. The UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) conducted a three-year investigation, which revealed the devastating toll the law is taking on women's health and rights in Poland. The report highlights that even in limited cases, such as when a woman's life or health is at risk, accessing a legal abortion is incredibly difficult. This has led to tragic incidents where women have died in Polish hospitals after being denied critical, life-saving care.

The restrictive abortion laws in Poland force women to endure unwanted pregnancies, seek unsafe and illegal abortions, or travel abroad for medical care, all of which come at great personal and financial cost. Women's bodily autonomy is infringed upon as they are denied the right to choose what happens to their own bodies. The laws also have a "chilling effect" on healthcare providers, who often refuse to perform even lawful abortions due to fear of prosecution. This further limits women's access to safe and legal abortions, putting their health and lives at risk.

The Polish government's intense scrutiny of women and girls seeking urgent healthcare related to miscarriages or legal medication abortions contributes to a climate of fear and intimidation. Women have reported being subjected to invasive searches and interrogations, treated like criminals, and denied their dignity and privacy. This not only violates their human rights but also discourages them from seeking the medical care they need, further endangering their health and well-being.

The negative impact of Poland's abortion laws extends beyond the physical and mental health consequences for women. The laws also affect reproductive healthcare providers, who face increased pressure and scrutiny from the government. There have been reports of doctors being targeted and raided by government agents, with their patients' medical records confiscated, violating patient privacy. Additionally, doctors who speak out against the abortion laws or provide support for abortion rights have faced repercussions, including job loss and public criticism.

The restrictive abortion laws in Poland have far-reaching consequences for women's health, bodily autonomy, and access to safe and legal reproductive healthcare. The laws infringe upon women's fundamental rights and freedoms, subjecting them to dangerous and degrading treatment. It is clear that Poland's abortion laws negatively impact women's health and bodily autonomy, and urgent legal reforms are needed to address these violations and ensure the protection of women's rights.

Polish women are forced to seek unsafe and illegal abortions or travel abroad for medical care

Poland's abortion laws are among the most restrictive in Europe. Abortion is only permitted if the mother's health is at risk, there is a fetal abnormality, or the pregnancy is a result of a criminal act, such as rape or incest. Even in these limited cases, accessing a legal abortion is extremely difficult, and many women are forced to seek unsafe and illegal abortions or travel abroad for medical care.

The United Nations (UN) has denounced Poland's restrictive abortion law, highlighting its devastating impact on women's health and rights. The law infringes on women's bodily autonomy and inflicts severe physical and mental suffering, amounting to "cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment." As a result, Polish women are often forced to endure unwanted pregnancies, putting their health and lives at risk.

The law's restrictive nature has led to tragic incidents where women have died in Polish hospitals after being denied critical, life-saving care. In addition, doctors often refuse to perform even lawful abortions, further endangering women's health. This has resulted in the deaths of several women whose pregnancies were not terminated despite complications that posed a danger to their health or lives.

The Polish government's intense scrutiny of women and girls seeking urgent healthcare has created a climate of fear and heightened risks. Women have been subjected to invasive searches and interrogations, treated as criminals, and put through degrading experiences that violate their human rights.

The government's pursuit of abortion-related activities extends beyond those seeking abortions to their social networks and healthcare providers. Friends, family members, and doctors have all been targeted in investigations, with patient confidentiality being violated and medical records confiscated. This has led to a sense of terror among those seeking or providing abortions, further limiting access to safe and legal procedures.

The impact of Poland's abortion laws reaches beyond its borders, as Polish women are forced to travel abroad for medical care. Germany, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, the UK, Austria, and Ukraine are among the destinations for those seeking abortions. This adds financial and logistical burdens to the already challenging situation these women face.

The restrictive abortion laws in Poland have sparked widespread protests, with Polish women and men taking to the streets in historic numbers. The "Black Protests" or "Black Monday" movement, inspired by similar demonstrations in Iceland, saw thousands of people demanding increased access to abortion and reproductive rights. While there have been some legislative efforts to liberalize abortion laws, conservative politicians continue to hold key positions that can block such changes.

The Polish government targets people for alleged abortion-related activities

Poland's abortion laws are among the most restrictive in Europe. Abortion is illegal unless the pregnancy is the result of a criminal act or when the pregnant woman's life or health is in danger. Even in these limited cases, accessing a legal abortion is challenging. Since the near-total ban on abortion in 2020, the Polish government has increasingly targeted people for alleged abortion-related activities, creating a climate of fear and heightening risks for women and girls. Here are some examples that illustrate how the government has targeted individuals:

Targeting Women and Girls

The Polish government has been accused of targeting women and girls who seek abortions or experience pregnancy loss. In one case, a 32-year-old woman named Joanna underwent a self-administered medication abortion, which is legal in Poland. However, when she contacted her psychiatrist due to severe anxiety, the psychiatrist called an ambulance and the police. Joanna was subjected to an invasive search at the hospital, where police officers ordered her to undress, squat, and cough. Such treatment has been criticised as degrading and a violation of human rights.

Another case involved a 17-year-old girl who took medication abortion pills and experienced excessive bleeding. Her friends called an ambulance, and she was taken to the hospital. The police searched her home and confiscated her phone and her mother's phone. She was interrogated as a witness to possible infanticide, and the police asked for names of people she had spoken to at abortion support groups. This interrogation occurred while the girl was still in the hospital, prioritising criminal investigation over her health and safety.

Targeting Healthcare Providers

Healthcare providers have also been targeted by the Polish government. Dr. Maria Kubisa, a gynecologist in Szczecin, Poland, had her private practice raided by six armed specialist government agents. They confiscated her computer, phones, and all patient medical records dating back to 1996, violating the privacy rights of her patients. The raid was related to allegations that Dr. Kubisa had provided an illegal abortion, which she denied. As a result of the confiscation of her belongings and records, Dr. Kubisa was unable to treat patients for weeks.

Another example is Dr. Dominik Przeszlakowski, an obstetrician-gynecologist in Krakow. He was fired from Jagiellonian University Hospital, one of Poland's largest public hospitals, after publicly criticising the Constitutional Tribunal's judgment on abortion. The hospital initially cancelled all scheduled abortion procedures but later reinstated them until the judgment came into force in January 2021. Dr. Przeszlakowski continued to object to the hospital's refusal to terminate pregnancies and was eventually fired, allegedly for failure to respond to a letter. He believes that his vocal critique of the Constitutional Tribunal's decision was the real reason for his dismissal.

Impact of Government Targeting

The targeting of individuals by the Polish government has had significant impacts on the lives and health of women and healthcare providers. It has created a climate of fear, with women and girls afraid to seek urgent medical care or abortions due to the risk of invasive investigations and prosecutions. Healthcare providers are also affected, as they may be hesitant to provide reproductive healthcare services for fear of prosecution. The government's actions have led to negative health outcomes and potential persecution for those seeking abortions or experiencing pregnancy loss.

There is a push to liberalise Poland's abortion laws

Poland's abortion laws are among the most restrictive in Europe. Abortion is only permitted when the mother's health is at risk, in the case of a fetal abnormality, or when the pregnancy is the result of rape or incest. Even in these limited cases, accessing a legal abortion is extremely challenging, and many women are forced to seek unsafe and illegal abortions or travel abroad for medical care. This has resulted in tragic incidents where women have died in Polish hospitals after being denied critical, life-saving care.

There is a growing push to liberalise Poland's abortion laws, with protests and legislative efforts gaining momentum. In April 2024, Polish lawmakers approved four amendments to the abortion laws in the first reading in parliament. The amendments aim to end Poland's cruel and draconian restrictions on abortion access, which have been denounced by Amnesty International and the United Nations (UN) as violations of human rights. The UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) has called for comprehensive abortion reforms, including legalising and decriminalising abortion, improving access to safe abortion services, and providing comprehensive sexual and reproductive healthcare.

Prime Minister Donald Tusk, who came to power in December, has vowed to legalise abortion until the 12th week of pregnancy. In April 2024, the Polish parliament debated liberalising the country's strict abortion law, with lawmakers considering four proposals. One of the proposals, introduced by Tusk's Civic Coalition, aims to legalise abortion up to the 12th week of pregnancy. However, conservatives in the government have delayed the debate, and conservative politicians hold key political positions that could block any changes.

The push to liberalise abortion laws in Poland is not without opposition. Conservative lawmakers have used graphic imagery and played the sound of a child's heartbeat during parliamentary debates. Anti-abortion groups have also held demonstrations outside the parliament building, expressing their strong support for the current restrictions. The issue remains deeply divisive, with protests and counter-protests taking place across the country.

Frequently asked questions