Trump's Abortion Law Agenda: What's The Real Story?

Former US President Donald Trump has been vocal about his stance on abortion laws, which has been a topic of discussion and scrutiny during his political career. Trump's views on abortion have been described as nuanced and contradictory, with his actions and statements often conflicting. While he takes credit for appointing Supreme Court justices who contributed to overturning Roe v. Wade, he also claims that his administration would uphold women's reproductive rights. Trump's position on abortion has shifted over time, and he has faced criticism from both conservatives and liberals for his statements and policies on the issue.

Trump's stance on abortion rights

Former US President Donald Trump has been vocal about his anti-abortion stance, which has been a central issue in his political campaigns. Trump has taken a hardline approach to abortion, with his administration significantly impacting women's reproductive rights in the US.

Striking Down Roe v. Wade

Trump played a pivotal role in overturning Roe v. Wade, the ruling that federally protected abortion rights since 1973. During his presidency, Trump appointed three conservative justices to the Supreme Court, who voted to strike down this ruling in the 2022 Dobbs v. Jackson case. This decision had far-reaching consequences, as Republican-led states swiftly enacted stringent abortion bans.

State-Level Abortion Policies

Trump has consistently advocated for leaving abortion policies to individual states, rather than having federal legislation. He has stated that abortion laws should be "up to the states to decide based on the will of their voters." This position has been criticised for allowing restrictive abortion laws to be implemented at the state level, severely limiting access to abortion services for many women.

Exceptions and Nuances

While generally opposed to abortion, Trump has expressed support for certain exceptions. He has stated that he favours exceptions in cases of rape, incest, or when the life of the mother is at risk. Additionally, he has acknowledged that some state abortion bans are too tough and has suggested that these laws will be redone in some way, without providing specific details.

In Vitro Fertilization (IVF)

Trump has also weighed in on the debate surrounding IVF, declaring himself the ""father of IVF"" during a town hall event. This statement sparked backlash and ridicule, especially from evangelical voters who oppose IVF due to their religious beliefs. Trump's stance on IVF is part of his attempt to appeal to women voters and address reproductive rights issues more broadly.

Post-Birth Abortion Claims

Trump has made controversial and misleading claims about "post-birth abortion," accusing his Democratic rivals of supporting the "execution" of babies after they are born. However, he appears to be referring to perinatal palliative care (PPC), a medical service that aims to improve quality of life for women and their babies after a severe fetal diagnosis or extreme prematurity. PPC involves forgoing life-extending interventions to maximise quality of life when survival is unlikely, and it is not an execution as Trump has characterised it.

Melania Trump's Stance

Interestingly, Trump's wife, Melania Trump, has publicly expressed a contrasting view on abortion. In her upcoming memoir, she passionately defends abortion rights, stating that restricting a woman's right to choose is equivalent to "denying her control over her own body." This divergence highlights the complexity of abortion rights within the Republican Party and Trump's family itself.

Trump's views on IVF

Donald Trump has referred to himself as the "father of IVF", a comment that has sparked backlash and ridicule from both Democrats and Republicans. Trump made this statement during a Fox News town hall event, where his flip-flopping on abortion also came under scrutiny.

Trump's comment about being the "father of IVF" came in response to a town hall attendee who asked him about the impact of "abortion bans" on "access to IVF and other fertility treatments". After his comment, Trump shared an anecdote about a phone call with Republican Alabama Senator Katie Britt, whom he described as "a young, just a fantastically attractive person from Alabama". He said that Britt had called him in a panic because an Alabama judge had ruled that IVF clinics were illegal. Trump admitted that he had asked Britt to "explain IVF very quickly" and that "within about two minutes, I understood it. I said, no, no, we're totally in favour of IVF."

Trump has also pledged to promote IVF by requiring health insurance companies or the federal government to pay for it. This stance is at odds with much of his own party, and risks alienating evangelical women who oppose IVF, a key voting block that his campaign needs to win over.

Trump's stance on IVF is part of a broader pattern of inconsistency on abortion and reproductive rights. He has shifted between boasting about nominating the Supreme Court justices who helped overturn Roe v. Wade and trying to appear more neutral. He has also flip-flopped on specific abortion laws, such as Florida's six-week ban, and on whether he would support a national abortion ban.

Trump's views on reproductive rights

Donald Trump's views on reproductive rights have been a central issue in his presidential campaigns and his presidency. His stance on abortion has been a particular focus, with his administration seeing a severe deterioration of women's reproductive rights. Notably, three Supreme Court justices installed during Trump's presidency voted to strike down Roe v. Wade, which had protected federal abortion rights since 1973. This decision resulted in Republican-run states implementing stringent abortion bans.

Trump has attempted to distance himself from these abortion bans, claiming that he would prefer for individual states to set their abortion policies. He has stated that he would veto any federal abortion ban passed by Congress and that he supports exceptions for rape, incest, and when the mother's life is at risk. However, his responses to questions regarding abortion have often been evasive and contradictory. For example, he criticised Florida's six-week abortion ban but later said he would vote against a ballot measure to expand abortion rights in the state.

Trump's stance on abortion has been a subject of criticism from both sides of the political aisle. His wife, Melania Trump, has publicly expressed her support for abortion rights, stating that restricting a woman's right to choose is the same as denying her control over her body. On the other hand, Trump has faced backlash from conservatives for his support for in-vitro fertilisation (IVF) and his declaration that he is the "father of IVF". This statement has been met with ridicule and confusion, especially from evangelical voters who oppose IVF due to religious teachings.

Trump's alternative to setting a clear policy on abortion has been to delegate the issue to the states. However, he has also acknowledged that some states have gone too far in restricting abortions and has promised to redo the regulations without providing specific details.

In addition to abortion, Trump has also addressed other reproductive rights issues, such as transgender kids in sports. He has stated that he would ban transgender athletes from participating in women's sports, a stance that has been criticised for failing to provide a viable path to action.

Trump's views on the Supreme Court

Donald Trump has had a complicated relationship with the Supreme Court. On the one hand, he has been the beneficiary of several favourable rulings, including being granted broad criminal immunity. This has been criticised by some, including a senior judge on the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Stephen S. Trott, who wrote in an op-ed that the ruling had created "a kingdom within our republic".

Trump's relationship with the Supreme Court is also notable because of his role in shaping the Court's ideological makeup through his appointments of conservative justices. During his presidency, Trump appointed three new justices to the Court: Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett. These appointments shifted the Court to the right and were celebrated by Trump's conservative base.

Trump has also been vocal about his desire to see the Supreme Court overturn Roe v. Wade, the ruling that protected federal abortion rights since 1973. In 2022, three justices appointed by Trump voted to strike down this ruling, allowing Republican-run states to institute strict abortion bans. However, Trump has tried to distance himself from these abortion bans, saying that abortion rights should be decided by individual states. This position has been criticised as an attempt to have it both ways, and it has caused division within the Republican Party.

Trump's views on the Dobbs decision

On the one hand, Trump has celebrated the decision, taking credit for it and calling it "the biggest WIN for LIFE in a generation". He has also hinted at supporting a federal abortion ban at 15 weeks of pregnancy, with exceptions for rape, incest, and when the mother's life is at risk.

On the other hand, Trump has also expressed ambivalence about overturning Roe v. Wade, speculating that it might be "bad for Republicans" and lead to a backlash among suburban women voters. He has also stated that he would not support a federal abortion ban "under any circumstances" and that abortion policy should be set by individual states.

In the aftermath of the Dobbs decision, Trump blamed "anti-abortion extremism" for Republican candidates' underperformance in the midterm elections.

Frequently asked questions