Abortion Laws: Which Country Leads The Way?

Abortion laws vary widely across the world, ranging from abortion being freely available on request to outright prohibition in all circumstances. In 2024, France became the first country to explicitly protect abortion rights in its constitution, while Yugoslavia implicitly inscribed abortion rights to its constitution in 1974. According to a report by Women on Waves, approximately 25% of the world's population lives in countries with highly restrictive abortion laws, with the Center for Reproductive Rights reporting that the inability to access safe and legal abortion care impacts 700 million women of reproductive age. In this context, the question of which country has the best abortion laws is highly subjective and depends on one's personal beliefs and values. However, it is worth noting that the global trend in abortion law is moving towards liberalization, with more than 60 countries having liberalized their abortion laws in the past 30 years.

Abortion laws in the US

Until 2022, federal protections for a pregnant woman's right to get an abortion were in place, following Supreme Court rulings in Roe v. Wade (1973) and Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992). These rulings ensured that states could not ban abortion before the point at which a fetus may be deemed viable. However, this changed with the Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization ruling in 2022, which removed nationwide protections for abortion rights and gave states the authority to impose their own regulations on abortion.

As a result, there is now a patchwork of abortion laws across the US, with 14 states enacting near-total abortion bans, and four states banning abortion after six weeks of pregnancy. On the other hand, some states have enacted laws or held ballot referendums to protect abortion rights. The future of abortion in a handful of other states is uncertain due to ongoing legal challenges.

Public opinion on abortion in the US is divided, with a majority of Americans believing that abortion should be legal in at least some situations. According to a Gallup poll from May 2024, 35% believe abortion should be legal "under any circumstances", 50% say it should be legal "only under certain circumstances", and 12% say it should be "illegal in all circumstances". Support for abortion tends to decrease as the pregnancy progresses, with two-thirds of Americans saying it should be legal in the first trimester, but only 22% supporting legality in the third trimester.

Abortion laws in Europe

Abortion laws vary across Europe, with the majority of countries allowing terminations in the first 12-14 weeks of pregnancy. However, there are still a few countries that impose stricter restrictions or even total bans on abortion. Here is an overview of abortion laws in Europe:

France

France has been a pioneer in abortion rights, becoming the first country to make a woman's free choice to request an abortion a constitutional right in March 2024. This move guarantees women the freedom to end an unwanted pregnancy up until 14 weeks. The country has a long history of supporting abortion rights, with abortion being legal since a landmark law passed in 1974, and 80% of French people expressing support for pro-choice policies.

Poland

Poland introduced a de-facto abortion ban in early 2021, permitting terminations only in cases of rape, incest, or if the mother's health or life is at risk. This ban sparked mass protests and has faced opposition from some politicians. However, Poland remains an outlier in Europe, with abortion largely inaccessible to women in the country.

United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom, abortion is permitted up to 24 weeks of pregnancy. There is no time limit if the woman's life is at risk or in cases of serious foetal abnormality. During the COVID-19 pandemic, a "pills-by-post" scheme was introduced, allowing women to end pregnancies at home up to 10 weeks, with abortions after this point being carried out in clinics.

Malta

Malta, a staunchly Catholic island nation, previously had a complete ban on abortion. However, in 2023, the country amended its laws to allow terminations when a woman's life is endangered. Despite this change, abortion remains illegal in all other circumstances, including rape, incest, and severe foetal abnormalities.

Italy

Italy, a traditionally Catholic country, has allowed abortions within 90 days of conception since 1978. However, accessing abortion services can be challenging due to a significant number of gynaecologists refusing to perform the procedure on moral or religious grounds. The right-wing prime minister, Giorgia Meloni, opposes abortion but has pledged not to change the law.

Spain

Spain has made significant strides in abortion legislation, with parliament approving legislation in 2023 to allow girls aged 16 and 17 to have abortions without parental consent. The mandatory three-day "reflection" period for women seeking terminations was also removed. Spain's abortion reform allows women to end pregnancies on demand within 14 weeks or up to 22 weeks in cases of severe foetal abnormalities.

Germany

In Germany, women can legally have an abortion within 12 weeks of conception, but they must undergo counselling and adhere to other formal restrictions. Abortion remains a criminal offence and can technically lead to jail sentences of up to three years, although prosecutions are rare. There have been recent discussions about fully decriminalising abortion within the first 12 weeks of pregnancy.

Hungary

Hungary has had a long-standing law allowing abortion in the first 12 weeks since 1953. However, in 2022, the country tightened its restrictions, requiring women to listen to the foetal heartbeat before seeking an abortion. Hungary is among several European countries that mandate counselling for women before ending a pregnancy.

Ireland

Ireland, a predominantly Catholic country, lifted its near-total ban on abortion in 2019 following a landslide referendum in 2018. Prior to this, approximately 3,000 women travelled to Britain annually for terminations. Abortion is now permitted up to 12 weeks of pregnancy and later if the foetus has a terminal condition or the woman's health is at risk.

Abortion laws in Latin America

Latin America is home to some of the most restrictive abortion laws in the world. Only four countries in the region—Cuba, Puerto Rico, Uruguay, and Argentina—allow abortions nationwide and without restrictions. In most other countries, abortions are only permitted when the pregnant person's life is at risk or in other specific circumstances, such as when the pregnancy is the result of rape or incest. In Chile, El Salvador, and the Dominican Republic, abortions are completely prohibited and carry criminal sanctions with no exceptions.

In recent years, there has been a push for liberalization in several Latin American countries. Colombia, Mexico, Argentina, and other countries in the region have seen a new era of liberalization, with abortion rights being recognized as fundamental human rights. In 2020, Argentina legalized abortion regardless of the cause, up until the 14th week of pregnancy. Previously, voluntary pregnancy interruption was only allowed under certain circumstances, such as in cases of rape or if the pregnant person's health or life was in danger.

Public opinion on abortion in Latin America is divided. A 2020 survey found that over one-third of Latin Americans supported legalizing voluntary pregnancy terminations under certain circumstances, while 26% believed abortion should be allowed if a woman so decides. However, 29% of respondents thought that abortion should be forbidden on principle.

Restrictive abortion laws have severe consequences for women's health and lives. In countries where abortion is illegal or highly restricted, millions of abortions are still performed every year, mostly under unsafe and clandestine conditions, and thousands of women die as a result. Maternal mortality due to unsafe abortions is a leading cause of death for women in the region.

International human rights law and bodies have increasingly supported the claims of Latin American women's organizations fighting for the right to safe and legal abortion. Advancing access to safe and legal abortion is recognized as integral to fulfilling women's human rights, including their reproductive rights, right to health, right to life, and right to equality.

Abortion laws in Asia

Abortion laws vary across Asia. In South Asia, one in four maternal deaths occur due to a lack of access to safe and legal abortions and contraceptives. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), less than half of the abortions in South and Central Asia were safe.

Bhutan, for example, only permits abortions if the mother's life is in danger, if the pregnancy resulted from incest or rape, or if the mother is not of sound mental condition. As a result, many Bhutanese women travel to neighbouring India, where abortion is legal on most grounds, although it remains dangerous. India's abortion law allows abortions up to 24 weeks and does not impose marital status as a limitation. However, the law does not grant women full agency, leaving the final decision to doctors. Nepal is the only South Asian country that permits abortions on request. Despite this, awareness of abortion legality remains low, and access to safe abortions is limited.

In Sri Lanka and Afghanistan, abortion laws are highly restrictive and punitive. Abortion is only permitted in Afghanistan if the mother's life is in danger or if the child is at risk of being born with severe disabilities. Sri Lanka has attempted to reform its abortion laws multiple times, but these efforts have failed due to anti-abortion sentiments.

In Pakistan, abortion is only allowed to protect the mother's life or physical health. A survey revealed that only 68% of women who undergo clandestine abortions obtain the procedure from medical professionals, while the rest face an elevated risk of complications by turning to traditional providers, pharmacists, or self-inducing.

Abortion laws in Africa

Abortion laws vary significantly across Africa, with countries such as South Africa, Nigeria, and Ghana providing a range of perspectives on the issue.

Nigeria

Abortion in Nigeria is illegal and carries a heavy prison sentence of up to 14 years, unless it is performed to save the pregnant woman's life. This stance reflects a disregard for women's reproductive rights and bodily autonomy, and it has severe consequences for women's health. The restrictive abortion laws in Nigeria lead many women to resort to dangerous backstreet abortion procedures, resulting in high maternal death rates and morbidity in the country. The need for legal reform to allow for safe and legal abortions is crucial to addressing this issue.

Ghana

Ghana's abortion laws are moderately permissive, allowing abortions to be carried out by licensed health workers in approved institutions in cases of rape, incest, fetal deformity, or to protect physical or mental health. However, abortion remains highly stigmatized in Ghana, leading to a high frequency of clandestine abortions. Complications from unsafe abortions contribute significantly to the country's high maternal mortality rate. Efforts to expand post-abortion care and safe abortion services are impeded by stigmatization, poor knowledge of abortion's legal status, and inadequate access to services.

South Africa

South Africa is recognized as one of the most liberal countries in Africa regarding reproductive rights. Abortion was legalized in South Africa in 1996 through the Choice in Termination of Pregnancy Act, which allows women of any age or marital status to access abortion services upon request during the first 12 weeks of pregnancy. In certain cases, such as when the pregnancy poses a risk to the woman's health or resulted from rape or incest, abortions are permitted until the 20th week of pregnancy. The liberal abortion laws in South Africa have played a role in reducing abortion-related mortality rates. However, there is still a market for backstreet abortions, highlighting the complex interplay between legal frameworks and cultural attitudes.

Frequently asked questions