Insurance Companies: Lawbreakers By Market Exit?

Insurance companies exiting markets is a worrying sign for the industry. While it is not uncommon for insurers to pull out of specific markets, a recent spate of withdrawals has spanned a range of business lines, companies, and regions. This trend has made it harder for policyholders to find coverage at a reasonable price, especially for insurance against pandemics.

In the US, insurance business is exempted from federal regulation and is instead governed by individual states. Each state has its own set of statutes and rules, and insurance companies must be licensed by the state to operate. While state regulation is designed to protect policyholders' interests, not all governments are effectively equipped to deal with insurers' exits from the market. Some lack well-structured and transparent regulation.

Insurance companies exit markets for a variety of internal and external reasons. They may be responding to a failure to meet sustainability targets, or to increasing costs of operation caused by changes in government policy, economic conditions, market competition, or developments in the legal liability environment, among other factors.

In the case of long-term care insurance, a study found that the most cited reason for leaving the market was profitability challenges. High capital requirements to support the product were cited as the single most important reason for market exit.

Insurance companies delaying investigations into claims

Insurance companies are required by law to investigate claims in a timely manner. However, investigations are often delayed, and this can be for a multitude of reasons.

Firstly, investigations are time-sensitive. For example, damage from a storm or car accident is not permanent, and if a vehicle has been damaged, the owner will want to get it repaired as soon as possible. If an insurer fails to launch an investigation within a reasonable time, the claim may be affected. In the state of Pennsylvania, insurance companies have 30 days to investigate a claim or to deny or accept it. If there is a legitimate reason for a delay, the company must provide a "reasonable written explanation" for the hold-up.

Sometimes, insurance companies will delay an investigation when they know they will be responsible for a large payout. They may also only investigate the areas pointed out to them by the claimant and not the entire situation. Additionally, they may send out unlicensed or third-party adjusters who do not fully investigate all relevant facts of a claim.

Another reason for delaying investigations is that insurance companies are in the business of making money. The more claims they deny, the more profit they make. Therefore, they may engage in bad faith or illegal actions during the claims investigation process to deny policyholders the damages they are due.

Insurance companies may also delay investigations by creating bureaucratic obstacles. They may request unnecessary records and documents, redundant documentation, or claim they need more information. They may also perform overly long investigations, making the claims process confusing and difficult, and leading policyholders to feel frustrated and overwhelmed. The hope is that claimants will give up or fail to complete the necessary steps, allowing the insurance company to avoid paying the claim.

Delays in insurance claim investigations can have serious financial and emotional consequences for policyholders. After an accident, disaster, or medical emergency, people often rely on timely insurance payouts to cover urgent expenses. When insurance companies stall the process, policyholders may face mounting bills, increased stress, and, in some cases, financial ruin.

Failure to conduct investigations

Insurance companies are required to conduct investigations and provide a fair deal to their customers. When a customer files a claim, the insurance company must investigate it, even if it is just sending an adjuster to review the damage.

Failure to conduct an investigation could be a violation of the law. For example, if a customer's car is damaged while parked on a street and their insurance company denies the claim without sending an adjuster or refuses to look at estimates collected by the customer, the insurance company is not acting in good faith.

State laws have deadlines for when an insurance company must accept or deny a claim, ranging from 15 to 60 days. If an insurance company delays an investigation beyond these dates, they may be breaking the law.

In the context of the recent COVID-19 pandemic, the market has become challenging for insured individuals and businesses. Many insurance companies have withdrawn from specific markets, lines of business, or regions, reducing capacity in the marketplace. This has made it harder for policyholders to find coverage at a reasonable price, especially for insurance against pandemics.

In the United States, insurance is regulated by individual states, with each state having its own statutes and rules. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) develops model rules and regulations for the industry, which must be approved by state legislatures. State insurance departments oversee insurer solvency, market conduct, and requests for rate increases.

While insurance companies exiting the market is not a new phenomenon, the recent spate of withdrawals across a range of business lines, companies, and regions is concerning. This trend is not limited to a specific region or type of insurance and has been observed in the US, UK, Australia, Germany, Japan, New Zealand, and other countries.

Offering low settlement amounts

There are several reasons why insurance companies offer low settlement amounts. Firstly, they are profit-driven and aim to pay out as little as possible to increase their bottom line. They use auto-computed software to determine settlement amounts, which may not take into account all the unique aspects of an individual's injuries. Additionally, insurance adjusters may not have all the necessary information about the claimant's injuries, medical bills, or property damage, leading to a lower offer.

When dealing with a low settlement offer, it is essential to remember that you are not required to accept it. You can negotiate by sending a written response and providing additional documentation, such as medical records, bills, and repair estimates. Consulting with a personal injury lawyer can help ensure that you don't undermine the value of your claim.

In some cases, if negotiations fail, you may need to file a lawsuit. However, it is important to carefully consider the value of your case and the policy limits before taking legal action, as it can be costly.

To summarize, while offering low settlement amounts is a common practice in the insurance industry, it can become illegal if insurance companies act in bad faith. It is crucial to understand your rights and the full value of your case to ensure you receive a fair settlement.

Misrepresentation of the law

Insurance companies are required by law to act in good faith and provide their customers with a fair deal. However, there have been instances where insurance companies have misrepresented the law or the language of a policy to avoid paying a claim.

Insurance agents have a duty to be truthful in their statements, and making false statements may be a violation of the law. In court, it must be proven that the statements made were intentionally false and intended to mislead.

In the United States, insurance is regulated by individual states, and each state has its own set of statutes and rules. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) is responsible for developing model rules and regulations for the industry, which must be approved by state legislatures.

State insurance departments oversee insurer solvency, market conduct, and requests for rate increases. They also play a crucial role in protecting the financial interests of insurance claimants and policyholders in the event of an insurance company exiting the market.

While specific regulations vary across states, three principles guide every state's rate regulation system:

• Rates should be adequate to maintain insurance company solvency.
• Rates should not be excessive or lead to exorbitant profits.
• Rates should not be unfairly discriminatory, with price differences reflecting expected claim and expense variations.

Threatening statements

Insurance companies are regulated by the state, and this system of regulation is underpinned by the McCarran-Ferguson Act of 1945, which describes state regulation and taxation of the industry as being in "the public interest". Each state has its own set of statutes and rules. State insurance departments oversee insurer solvency, market conduct and requests for rate increases for coverage, among other things.

Any insurance company that makes threatening statements to a policyholder may be prosecuted under the law. If an insurance agent tells a policyholder that if they file a claim, the company will file legal action against them, it is important that the policyholder contacts their state insurance board as well as an attorney right away.

Insurance companies are required to act in good faith and provide policyholders with a fair deal. This means they must investigate any claim filed, even if it is simply sending an adjustor to review damage. If an insurance company denies a claim without sending out an adjustor or refuses to look at estimates provided by the policyholder, they are not acting in good faith.

Insurance companies are also required to provide policyholders with certain information. Failure to disclose the existence of coverage, notify policyholders of a claim deadline, or provide necessary paperwork to complete a claim may all constitute violations of the law.

Additionally, insurance companies are not allowed to purposely offer far lower settlements than they know a claim is worth. If a policyholder has provided estimates for damage repairs and their policy has adequate coverage to pay those claims, the insurance company may not offer a settlement that is less than the lowest estimate received.

Finally, insurance agents have a duty to be truthful in their statements. There have been instances when insurance companies have purposely misrepresented the law or the language of a policy to avoid paying a claim. Making false statements may be a violation of the law, and policyholders can take legal action if they can prove that the statements made by the insurance company were intentionally false and intended to mislead.

Frequently asked questions