Lease Agreements: Can They Override The Law?

The relationship between lease agreements and the law is a complex one. While a lease is a contract, it cannot contradict the law. Local laws may prohibit certain provisions, and the law controls in the event of a conflict. For example, a lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law. However, a properly worded lease can lengthen or shorten the usual notice periods in some states. The interpretation of lease agreements versus the law is often best left to legal professionals, as the language of the law can be difficult to interpret.

Local laws may prohibit lease provisions

While a lease is a legally binding contract, it does not always override state law. Local laws may prohibit certain lease provisions, and a lease cannot contradict the law. Landlord-tenant laws can be reactionary, difficult to interpret, and unresponsive, making it challenging for landlords to navigate the legal landscape.

For example, in the state of Georgia, a month-to-month tenant is required to give 30 days' notice before terminating their lease, according to state law (O.C.G.A. § 44-7-7). However, a written lease agreement may require a longer notice period, such as 45 or 60 days. In this case, the lease agreement may supersede state law. Nonetheless, a lawyer would need to review the specific lease agreement to provide a final opinion, as the legal implications can vary depending on the contract's particulars.

Local laws may also dictate specific provisions that are prohibited in lease agreements. For instance, a lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law. Provisions regarding the payment of attorneys' fees, forgoing litigation, or waiving a landlord's liability for the condition of the property may be considered illegal. It is crucial to tailor lease agreements to comply with local laws to avoid any legal pitfalls.

To ensure compliance with local laws, landlords should seek legal advice from a landlord attorney or a tenant verification service before finalizing a lease agreement. This proactive approach can help identify any provisions that may be prohibited or contradict local laws, reducing the risk of legal issues in the future. By understanding the local legal landscape, landlords can strike the right balance between the freedom to enter into contracts and adhering to landlord-tenant laws.

In summary, while a lease is a legally binding document, it must operate within the boundaries set by local laws. Local laws may prohibit specific lease provisions to protect the rights and interests of tenants. By staying informed about applicable laws and seeking legal advice, landlords can create lease agreements that are both comprehensive and compliant.

Leases don't always mean what they say

In a tenancy at will or month-to-month situation, a landlord must give the tenant 60 days' notice to terminate, whereas a tenant need only give 30 days' notice. However, if there is a written lease for a defined term, the lease will probably control. A properly worded lease can lengthen or shorten the usual notice periods. For example, a lease may specify a 60-day written notice before termination, whereas the state law may only require 30 days.

The only way a lawyer can answer for sure is to read the entire lease. It is recommended to ask a local landlord attorney to review a lease before asking a tenant to sign. Many leases contain a "severability" clause that allows any illegal portion to be severed from the remaining contract, which remains in force.

The right balance between the freedom to enter into contracts and landlord-tenant law

The relationship between contract law and landlord-tenant law is a complex one. While a lease is a contract, and contracts are generally upheld by the law, there are instances where a lease may be superseded by landlord-tenant law. This is because landlord-tenant laws are often reactionary, difficult to interpret, and unresponsive to the needs of landlords. As such, the law tends to favour tenants over landlords.

For example, in the state of Georgia, a month-to-month tenant is required to give 30 days' notice before terminating their lease. However, a landlord must give 60 days' notice to terminate. This is an example of landlord-tenant law superseding the terms of a lease, as a landlord could not enforce a shorter termination period than what is outlined in the law, even if the tenant had agreed to this in the lease.

Additionally, local laws may prohibit certain provisions in a lease. For instance, a lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law. Provisions regarding the payment of attorneys' fees, forgoing litigation, or waiving a landlord's liability for the conditions of the property may be considered illegal. In these cases, a "severability" clause may be included in the lease, which allows the illegal portion to be severed from the remaining contract, which remains in force.

To strike the right balance between the freedom to enter into contracts and landlord-tenant law, it is essential to tailor lease agreements to local laws. Consulting a local landlord attorney before finalising a lease agreement can help ensure that the lease complies with the relevant laws and does not infringe on the rights of either party.

Ultimately, while a lease is a legally binding contract, it is subject to the applicable landlord-tenant laws, which may override certain provisions to protect the rights of tenants.

A lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection under the law

While leases are contracts, they do not always mean what they say and do not always override state laws. The law controls, and a lease cannot contradict the law. For instance, if the state law says that a deposit must be returned within 30 days, a landlord cannot extend that deadline, even with the tenant's agreement.

A lease also cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection under the law. For example, provisions regarding the payment of attorney fees, forgoing litigation, or waiving a landlord's liability for the property's conditions are potentially illegal.

In some cases, state laws can override lease provisions. For example, before 1968, tenants in California had to demand a change in the lease before signing to ensure they had the right to collect attorney fees. However, Section 1717 of the California Civil Code was passed in 1968, recognizing that the bargaining positions of the parties are not always equal and awarding attorney fees to the prevailing party when a contract includes a provision for attorney fees.

To avoid any legal issues, landlords should tailor lease agreements to local laws and have them reviewed by a local landlord attorney before asking a tenant to sign. Additionally, it is essential to understand that the language of the law can be difficult to interpret, and courts play a role in crafting landlord-tenant law by interpreting statutes, contracts, and personal injury law.

A lease is a contract and must be read and understood before signing

A lease is a contract, and as with any contract, it is important to read and understand the terms before signing. This is because a lease can have specific legal implications, and it is crucial to be aware of the rights and obligations it confers on both the landlord and the tenant.

In the context of lease agreements, there is an ongoing power struggle between the freedom to enter into contracts and the specific landlord-tenant laws that apply. This means that a lease cannot simply override state law; the law controls. For example, local laws may prohibit certain provisions, such as those requiring the tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law. Provisions regarding attorney fees, forgoing litigation, or waiving a landlord's liability for property conditions are all examples of potentially illegal lease provisions.

However, it is important to note that the specific state laws and local laws that apply to lease agreements can vary. Therefore, it is advisable to tailor any standard lease agreement to the local law and have it reviewed by a local lawyer before asking a tenant to sign. This is essential to ensure compliance with the law and to avoid any potential legal issues that may arise from an improperly drafted lease.

Additionally, it is worth noting that a lease may not always mean what it says. For instance, in the case of attorney fees, a contract may include a provision for attorney fees with specific wording, but the law may override this provision. As such, it is crucial to be aware of the applicable laws and how they may interact with the terms of the lease.

Frequently asked questions