Lease Agreements: State Law Vs Lease Contracts

The relationship between lease agreements and state law is a complex one, with landlords and tenants needing to be aware of their rights and responsibilities. While leases can impose certain requirements on tenants, they cannot supersede state law. For example, a lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law, such as the right to have a security deposit returned within a certain timeframe. Lease agreements must be tailored to local laws, and landlords should be aware that what is acceptable in one state may be illegal in another. This guide will explore the dynamic between lease agreements and state law, providing an overview of the key considerations for landlords and tenants.

Lease agreements cannot contradict state law

Provisions regarding the payment of attorney fees, forgoing litigation, or waiving a landlord's liability for the conditions of the property are all examples of potentially illegal lease provisions. Many leases contain a "severability" clause that allows inappropriate portions to be severed from the remaining contract, which remains in force. If the lease contract is premised on an illegal provision, the landlord may find there is no way to enforce any of the provisions of the lease.

For example, a lease might state that a 60-day notice is required to vacate an apartment, whereas the state law might state that 30 days is acceptable. In this case, the lease agreement cannot supersede state law, and the tenant would be required to give only 30 days' notice. Similarly, a landlord might state that only three days' worth of rent is refundable after vacating, whereas state law might require that the rent from the day of vacating until the end of the month is refunded. Again, state law would supersede the lease agreement in this case.

It is important to note that there is an ongoing power struggle between the freedom to enter into contracts and landlord-tenant law. The right balance must be struck in each individual lease agreement. When drafting a lease agreement, it is crucial to tailor it to the local law and have it reviewed by a local landlord attorney before asking a tenant to sign.

Local laws may prohibit certain lease provisions

Lease agreements contain a variety of provisions, including broader use provisions, which outline the rights and responsibilities of both the landlord and tenant. However, it is important to note that a lease does not supersede state law. Local laws may prohibit certain lease provisions, and it is the responsibility of both landlords and tenants to understand their obligations under the lease and applicable local laws.

In some cases, landlords may include provisions in the lease that are illegal or contradict state law. For example, a lease might state a longer notice period for termination than what is required by state law, as seen in the case of Ohio. Similarly, a lease might try to limit the landlord's liability for negligence or injuries, waive the tenant's right to a jury trial, or impose unreasonable restrictions on guests or pets, which may be prohibited by local laws.

State laws, such as those in California and New York, may also encourage family-run daycares and allow landlords to limit the number of children or impose regulations on the minimum size of the facility and fire exits. Landlords in these states may restrict tenants from running daycares or other businesses from the rental property, citing clauses specifying "residential purposes only."

Tenants should be aware of their rights and carefully review lease agreements before signing. They can consult online resources like Nolo or LawAtlas to understand landlord-tenant laws in their state and locality. By being informed, tenants can identify and challenge illegal or abusive lease clauses.

In summary, local laws play a crucial role in governing the landlord-tenant relationship and can prohibit certain lease provisions. Both landlords and tenants should be diligent in understanding their legal obligations to ensure fair and compliant lease agreements.

Leases cannot waive a right guaranteed under law

Leases cannot supersede state law. In other words, a lease cannot waive a right guaranteed under law. For example, in Texas, landlords cannot include a clause in the lease that waives their responsibility to repair conditions that affect a tenant's health or safety. If they do so, they are liable to the tenant for actual damages, one month's rent, $2000, and reasonable attorney's fees.

Similarly, in Ohio, the state code takes precedence over the lease agreement. For instance, if a lease states that a 60-day notice is required before vacating the property, but the Ohio Revised Code states that 30 days is acceptable, the tenant is only required to give 30 days' notice.

In another example, a lease might include a clause stating that tenants can only pursue legal action within 30 days of terminating the lease, while state law allows for a four-year statute of limitations on damages. In this case, the tenant would still be entitled to pursue legal action within the four-year timeframe allowed by state law.

It is important to note that the doctrine of contra proferentem favors the tenant in these situations, unless they are the party that drafted the lease contract, which is typically the landlord in a landlord-tenant context. Therefore, it is crucial to understand the applicable state laws and tenant rights when entering into a lease agreement.

Lease contracts can be tailored to local laws

Lease agreements are legally binding contracts between landlords and tenants. They outline the rental terms and protect both parties. Lease contracts can be tailored to local laws, and landlords must ensure that their lease agreements meet all legal requirements. For example, in New York, lease agreements are governed by state and local laws, and landlords must ensure that their contracts include all the elements required by law, such as property descriptions, lease terms, rent amounts, and security deposit details. Similarly, lease agreements in Texas are subject to state laws that outline what can and cannot be included in a lease. Texas law, for instance, prevents landlords from restricting a tenant's right to possess a firearm in a rental unit.

It is important to note that lease agreements cannot supersede state law. In other words, a lease agreement cannot invalidate or override a state law. For instance, a lease agreement cannot restrict a tenant's rights that are guaranteed under the law. In Texas, for example, landlords cannot include clauses that waive their responsibility to repair conditions affecting a tenant's health or safety. If a landlord includes such a clause, they are liable for actual damages, one month's rent, and reasonable attorney's fees.

To ensure compliance with local laws, tenants should carefully review the lease agreement before signing. They should seek legal advice for unclear or complex terms and confirm that all verbal agreements are included in the contract. Tenants should also be aware of their rights and responsibilities under state and local laws to identify any discrepancies between the lease agreement and the applicable laws. For example, tenants in California are subject to a four-year statute of limitations on damages, despite some lease agreements claiming a six-month limitation.

Landlords, on the other hand, should be diligent in drafting lease agreements that comply with local laws. They should be familiar with the specific regulations in their area and include all the necessary elements in the contract. Landlords can use templates or customized agreements to ensure compliance with state laws. Additionally, landlords should be aware of their duties, such as providing a safe and habitable environment for tenants and making legal disclosures related to health and safety codes. By understanding their obligations, landlords can avoid potential legal challenges and establish a harmonious rental relationship with their tenants.

State law may dictate lease termination and refund policies

A lease is a contract that binds two or more parties to the terms of the agreement. However, it does not supersede state law. In fact, certain laws provide protections for tenants that are not waivable. For example, if a tenant is injured due to the landlord's negligence, most state laws dictate that the landlord is responsible for damages. Thus, a lease waiving the landlord's responsibility for injuries caused by their negligence would render that lease void.

State laws may dictate lease termination policies. For instance, in California, landlords must refund security deposits within 21 days after a tenant moves out. The full deposit should be returned unless deductions are necessary for unpaid rent or repairs due to significant wear and tear. Landlords must provide a detailed list of repairs carried out using the deposit funds in the case of deductions. In Ohio, the state law states that 30 days' notice is acceptable, whereas a lease may state a longer period, such as 60 days.

State laws may also dictate refund policies. For example, if a lease is considered unenforceable or void, it is terminated as if it was never signed, and any security deposits paid should be returned. In California, landlords have the right to withhold security deposits and evict tenants for breaching agreements. However, they must also provide habitable dwelling units and respond reasonably to repair requests.

Additionally, state laws may outline the reasons for which a lease can be terminated. For example, a landlord may legally terminate a lease if the tenant has violated the terms of the lease or broken the law. The violation must be significant, such as late rent or having a pet when pets are prohibited. On the other hand, a tenant may be able to terminate a lease early if the landlord is violating health and safety codes or retaliating against the tenant for exercising their rights.

Frequently asked questions