Mental Health Disabilities: Impact On Legal Proceedings

Mental health-related disability claims are often denied, even when an individual's condition is severe and disabling. This is because insurers can easily deny these claims, and individuals may not know that they can appeal. To maximize the chances of winning disability payments for mental illness, one must be under the regular care of a family doctor who is following the best practices and, ideally, also be receiving treatment from a psychiatrist. In the US, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) governs private sector employee benefits plans, including disability plans. Title I complaints must be filed with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) within 180 days of the date of discrimination, or 300 days if the charge is filed with a designated state or local fair employment practice agency. Individuals may file a lawsuit in federal court only after they receive a right-to-sue letter from the EEOC. Complaints of title II violations may be filed with the Department of Justice within 180 days of the date of discrimination. In certain situations, cases may be referred to a mediation program sponsored by the Department of Justice, and the Department may bring a lawsuit where it has been unable to resolve violations.

Characteristics of psychiatric disability lawsuits

Mental health disability claims denied

Mental health disability claims are often denied due to a variety of reasons. Firstly, the subjective nature of mental illness poses challenges in evaluation and documentation. Mental health conditions cannot always be easily verified through objective medical tests or procedures, making it difficult to provide concrete evidence to support a claim.

Secondly, the Social Security Administration (SSA) relies heavily on medical records when evaluating disability claims. Insufficient or inadequate medical documentation, including poor treatment notes, can lead to claim denials. This includes a lack of detail about the impairment, related limitations, and treatment history. In some cases, individuals may not have received consistent or specialized mental health treatment, which can raise doubts about the validity of their claim.

Additionally, non-compliance with recommended treatment plans can result in claim denials. This includes refusing or failing to attend counseling sessions or group therapy as advised. The SSA may interpret this as a lack of commitment to improving one's condition, increasing the likelihood of denial.

Furthermore, the SSA considers an individual's ability to work despite their limitations. If an applicant is deemed employable in any capacity, their claim may be denied, even if they cannot return to their previous job. This assessment takes into account factors such as age and the extent to which the mental illness impacts daily functioning.

It is also important to note that insurance companies have implemented measures to manage mental health-related disability claims. This includes excluding mental illness claims from certain policies or creating specific procedures for handling such claims. Insurers may deny claims by arguing that a “toxic work environment” caused the mental illness, thereby exempting themselves from providing benefits.

Lastly, the involvement of a psychiatrist or specialized mental health professional in the treatment process is crucial. A lack of consultation with a psychiatrist can raise red flags for insurers, who may interpret it as a sign of insufficient care or question the validity of the claim.

To maximize the chances of a successful claim, individuals should ensure comprehensive medical documentation, regular treatment, and compliance with recommended therapies. Seeking legal advice and understanding one's rights under relevant laws, such as the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), can also be beneficial.

Insurers and disability benefits

Disability insurance is a type of insurance that provides supplementary income in the event a worker is unable to perform their work due to disability. This includes accidents, injuries, illnesses, and/or disabilities. Disability insurance plans vary in their terms and conditions, with more favourable plans carrying more expensive premiums. Key features that affect insurance premiums include the length of the elimination period (the time between becoming disabled and receiving benefits), the benefit period, and the strictness of the definition of "disability". For example, a worker with a high income and specialized profession may opt for a more expensive plan with a flexible definition of disability.

Disability income (DI) insurance is available through employers, the Social Security Administration, or private insurance companies. Policies pay benefits on a monthly basis, after a waiting period. This waiting period, or elimination period, is the number of days an individual is disabled before benefits kick in. The most common period is 90 days, and the shorter the elimination period, the more expensive the premium. It is important to note that disability insurance policies do not pay 100% of an employee's salary and may not guarantee job protection. However, certain protections are included in most policies, such as noncancelable clauses.

In the case of mental health disability claims, insurers may deny claims more frequently, even when an individual's condition is severe. One reason for this could be the failure to see a psychiatrist or receive regular care from a family doctor. To maximize the chances of winning disability payments for mental illness, it is recommended to be under the regular care of a family doctor and to receive treatment or consultation from a psychiatrist.

In terms of disability benefits law, there are specific guidelines to follow. For instance, benefits begin on the eighth consecutive day of disability, and the employer must provide a Statement of Rights under the Disability Benefits Law within five days of learning of the disability. Additionally, if a claim is rejected, the individual will receive a Notice of Rejection within 45 days, and they can request a review by mailing the Notice of Rejection to the Workers' Compensation Board Disability Benefits Bureau.

Disability rights laws

The ADA defines an individual with a disability as someone with a physical or mental impairment that significantly limits one or more major life activities or has a history of such impairment. People with certain disabilities may communicate differently, and the ADA recognises this by defining a service animal and outlining the rights of individuals who require such assistance.

The Civil Rights of Institutionalized Persons Act (CRIPA) is another crucial piece of legislation. It authorises the US Attorney General to investigate conditions at state and local government institutions, including prisons, jails, pretrial detention centres, juvenile correctional facilities, nursing homes, and institutions for people with psychiatric or developmental disabilities. The purpose is to uncover and address widespread deficiencies that jeopardise the health and safety of residents.

Other disability rights laws include the Air Carrier Access Act, which ensures accessible air travel, and the Voting Accessibility for the Elderly and Handicapped Act of 1984, which mandates physical accessibility at polling places during federal elections and provides alternative means of casting ballots when necessary. Additionally, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) governs private sector employee benefits plans, including disability benefits, and outlines the process for individuals to file lawsuits when they believe their plan rights have been violated.

Lawsuits against the Social Security Administration

During the pandemic, tens of thousands of people who rely on Supplemental Security Income (SSI) to survive experienced harmful disruptions to their benefits. In response, a class-action lawsuit was filed on behalf of five SSI recipients challenging the Social Security Administration's (SSA) practices. The lawsuit aimed to address the concerns of vulnerable citizens who depend on SSA benefits to survive and hold the SSA accountable for amending its pandemic response. The plaintiffs requested that the SSA fix the Agency's new simplified waiver process and stop imposing penalties on SSI recipients during the National Emergency.

In a separate incident, a coalition of unions and retirees, including AFSCME, sued the Social Security Administration to stop the unlawful seizure of people's personal data. The lawsuit alleged that the seizure of SSA data by the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), led by Elon Musk, violated the law, including the Privacy Act and the Federal Information Systems Modernization Act. The lawsuit aimed to protect the Social Security, pensions, and Medicare of retirees.

In another case, a federal judge reprimanded the Social Security Administration's acting commissioner, Lee Dudek, for threatening to shut down operations at the agency in response to a ruling barring DOGE access. The judge temporarily blocked DOGE from accessing individuals' personal data at the SSA. Dudek reversed his stance after receiving clarifying guidance from the court.

These lawsuits highlight the efforts of individuals and organizations to hold the Social Security Administration accountable for its actions and protect the rights and benefits of citizens who depend on SSA programs.

Statute of limitations

The statute of limitations is a law that sets forth the maximum period that can pass before legal proceedings may be initiated. In the context of psychiatric disabilities, the statute of limitations can vary depending on the specific circumstances and the laws of the relevant jurisdiction.

In the United States, the statute of limitations for filing a complaint under Title I of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is 180 days from the date of discrimination. If the charge is filed with a designated state or local fair employment practice agency, this period is extended to 300 days. Only after receiving a "right-to-sue" letter from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) can individuals file a lawsuit in federal court.

In certain cases, the statute of limitations for psychiatric disabilities may be affected by qualifiers such as "delayed expression" in Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) diagnoses. Mental health professionals use the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders to diagnose mental disorders, which recognizes that it can take months or years for full-blown PTSD to manifest. This late development could cause issues with the statute of limitations in certain acts, such as the Longshore and Defense Base Act.

For example, in a case involving a claimant with PTSD, the Second Circuit decided that the statute of limitations did not begin to run until the claimant was sent home from Kosovo, making the claim filed nearly two years after the shooting timely. This decision highlights that, in cases involving a statute of limitations issue, the focus is on when the claimant knew or should have known that the work-related injury caused an earning power impairment.

It is important to note that the statute of limitations may vary depending on the specific laws and regulations of the jurisdiction in which the lawsuit is being filed.

Frequently asked questions