Inmates Practicing Law: Legal Or Not?

In the United States, there is no blanket rule prohibiting inmates from practising law while incarcerated. However, it is highly unusual, and several factors come into play. Firstly, prisoners are rarely permitted to have jobs outside of those supplied by the prison, and they cannot simply leave the prison to work. Secondly, bar membership is typically suspended during incarceration, and people with felony convictions are usually not admitted to the practice of law. Thirdly, while some states have statutes that exempt jailhouse lawyers from licensing requirements, these lawyers can only assist other inmates with legal matters and cannot leave the prison to represent them in court.

Inmates are not allowed to leave prison to practice law

In the United States, bar membership is usually suspended while in prison. In addition, people with a felony conviction that is being served or is recent are usually not admitted to the practice of law. In most places, conviction of a serious crime or felony means that an individual cannot be a registered lawyer.

The term "jailhouse lawyer" refers to an inmate who informally assists other inmates in legal matters, usually without having practiced law or having any formal legal training. Many states in the US have jailhouse lawyer statutes, some of which exempt inmates acting as jailhouse lawyers from the licensing requirements imposed on other attorneys when they are helping indigent inmates with legal matters. However, this is a service that can be taken away or restricted, and states may lay down limitations on the times and places where such business can be conducted.

Inmates are not allowed to have jobs outside of prison

Prisoners are also usually unable to obtain a Release on Temporary Licence, which would allow them to leave prison to work. Furthermore, bar membership is often suspended while serving a prison sentence.

However, there are some instances where inmates have been able to practice law while incarcerated. For example, in the film *For Life* (2020), the protagonist works for the paralegal association, representing inmates in internal cases. This gives him unlimited access to the library, which he uses to obtain a law degree online and take the Vermont bar exam. He then applies to have his license reciprocally accepted in New York.

In the US, there are also jailhouse lawyer statutes in many states, which exempt inmates acting as jailhouse lawyers from the licensing requirements imposed on other attorneys when helping indigent inmates with legal matters. However, this service can be restricted or taken away, especially if abuse is found.

Inmates are not allowed to be registered as lawyers due to felony convictions

Prisoners in the US are typically only permitted to have jobs supplied by the prison. They cannot leave prison to work, and this includes working as a lawyer. While it is not unheard of for inmates to assist other inmates in legal matters, this is usually informal and often relates to sentence appeals, pardons, stays of execution, or prison conditions. This is known as 'jailhouse lawyering' and is distinct from the practice of law by a qualified lawyer.

The ability for inmates to act as 'jailhouse lawyers' and help other inmates file petitions for post-conviction relief was first recognised in Johnson v. Avery. This case also determined that unless states provide a reasonable alternative, they must permit such action. Many US states have jailhouse lawyer statutes, some of which exempt inmates acting as jailhouse lawyers from the licensing requirements imposed on other attorneys when helping indigent inmates with legal matters. However, this service can be taken away or restricted, and states may impose limitations if they find that inmates are being abused or are committing abuse.

In the fictional TV show For Life (2020), the protagonist, while in prison, takes a job with a paralegal association, representing inmates in internal cases. As a result, he gains access to the prison library, which he uses to obtain college and law degrees online. He then takes the Vermont bar exam, the only state where one can sit for the bar exam with a degree from a non-accredited law school. He applies to have his license reciprocally accepted in New York, with sponsorship from a legal professional. However, this is a fictional example, and it is unlikely that an inmate would be allowed to leave prison to work as a lawyer.

Inmates can be restricted from practising law

In addition, bar membership is usually suspended while in prison. While some US states have jailhouse lawyer statutes that exempt inmates acting as jailhouse lawyers from the licensing requirements imposed on other attorneys, this service can be taken away or restricted. States may impose limitations on the times and places where such business can be conducted, and restrictions can be placed on jailhouse lawyers if inmates are found to be committing abuse.

The ability for inmates to act as jailhouse lawyers and help other illiterate inmates file petitions for post-conviction relief was first recognised in Johnson v. Avery. The Supreme Court has held that jailhouse lawyers must be permitted to assist illiterate inmates in filing petitions for post-conviction relief unless the state provides some reasonable alternative. The Center for Constitutional Rights and National Lawyers Guild wrote The Jailhouse Lawyers Handbook in 2003 for inmates needing rudimentary information on jailhouse lawyering. The Columbia Human Rights Law Review of Columbia Law School also publishes a Jailhouse Lawyer's Manual, intended to help prisoners and jailhouse lawyers appeal their sentence, protest their conditions of imprisonment, etc.

Inmates can be given access to law libraries

The Supreme Court gave states several options to fulfill this mandate, including establishing law school clinical programs, employing staff attorneys, contracting with prisoner assistance organizations, and providing adequate law libraries. However, the Court did not specify what materials are necessary to ensure adequacy, leading to variations in how states operate their law libraries. The American Association of Law Libraries (AALL) has compiled a list of necessary law books, which has been regularly updated and is considered a minimum standard by most prison administrations.

Despite these efforts, inmates continue to file lawsuits alleging inadequate access to law libraries due to limited hours, schedule conflicts, limited space, disciplinary actions, and incomplete collections. Prison overcrowding further exacerbates these issues. In some cases, prison authorities have been accused of neglecting to upgrade law libraries and restrict prisoner access.

While inmates may be given access to law libraries, it is highly unusual for them to practice law while incarcerated. Prison work assignments are typically limited to jobs supplied by the prison, and inmates are generally unable to leave the prison to work. Additionally, bar membership is usually suspended during incarceration, and felony convictions often disqualify individuals from becoming registered lawyers.

Frequently asked questions