Codified Law: Can It Be Altered?

Codification is the process of arranging laws, rules, or regulations into a systematic code. This process does not create new law, but instead arranges existing law into a code, usually by subject. This helps to identify inconsistent, duplicate, or ambiguous laws and creates a uniform source that is easy to access for both professionals and the public. However, courts sometimes refer back to the original legislation or judicial proceeding when interpreting a codified law in order to understand the intent of the law's creator. Recodification refers to the process of reformatting and rewriting existing codified statutes into a new codified structure. This is often necessary as the legislative process of amending statutes and the legal process of construing statutes can change over time.

The process of codification

To codify something means to enshrine a right or a rule into a formal systematic code. This can be done through an act of Congress in the form of a federal law. State legislatures can also codify rights by enacting laws. For example, to codify Roe for all Americans, Congress would need to pass a law that would provide the same protections that Roe did – so a law that says women have a right to abortion without excessive government restrictions. It would be binding for all states.

Over time, the legislative process of amending statutes and the legal process of construing statutes may result in the need for recodification, where existing codified statutes are reformatted and rewritten into a new codified structure. For example, the 1916 Code of Canon Law was abrogated in 1983 by the 1983 Code of Canon Law.

Courts sometimes refer back to the original legislation or judicial proceeding when interpreting a codified law in order to understand the intent of the creator of the law.

Judicial decisions or legislative acts

Codified law can be changed through a process known as recodification, where existing codified statutes are reformatted and rewritten into a new codified structure. This process can involve taking judicial decisions or legislative acts and turning them into codified law. For example, in the United States, acts of Congress are codified chronologically in the order in which they became law at Congress.gov. However, the United States Code also codifies federal statutes by subject matter, which can help identify inconsistent, duplicate, or ambiguous laws.

The process of codification does not necessarily create new law but arranges existing law into a code. This can be done at the federal or state level, with state legislatures able to codify rights by enacting laws. For instance, to codify Roe for all Americans, Congress would need to pass a law providing the same protections, which would be binding for all states.

Despite the usefulness of codification for finding information, courts sometimes refer back to the original legislation or judicial proceeding when interpreting a codified law. This is to understand the intent of the creator of the law. Over time, the legislative process of amending statutes and the legal process of construing statutes may also lead to changes in codified law.

The intent of the law's creator

The process of codification does not create new law, but rather arranges existing law into a systematic code. This can involve taking judicial decisions or legislative acts and turning them into codified law. For example, in the United States, acts of Congress are codified chronologically, while the United States Code codifies federal statutes by subject matter.

State legislatures can also codify rights by enacting laws, as seen with the example of Roe v. Wade. Despite some politicians saying they want to "codify Roe," Congress is not looking to enshrine Roe in law. This highlights the importance of understanding the intent of the law's creator, as it can impact the interpretation and application of the law.

The process of amending statutes

To codify means to arrange laws, rules, or regulations into a systematic code. This process does not create new law, but merely arranges existing law, usually by subject, into a code. For example, in the United States, acts of Congress are codified chronologically in the order in which they became law at Congress.gov. The United States Code also codifies federal statutes by subject matter. The codification of law helps identify inconsistent, duplicate, and/or ambiguous laws. It also creates a uniform source that is easy to access for both professionals and the lay public.

However, codified law can be changed through a process called recodification, where existing codified statutes are reformatted and rewritten into a new codified structure. This process can involve taking judicial decisions or legislative acts and turning them into codified law. For example, in 1916, the Commission for the Codification of Canon Law was completed, which contained 2,414 canons and was in force until 1983 when it was abrogated by the 1983 Code of Canon Law.

State legislatures can also codify rights by enacting laws. For instance, to codify Roe for all Americans, Congress would need to pass a law that provides the same protections that Roe did, such as the right to abortion without excessive government restrictions. This would be binding for all states.

Additionally, courts sometimes refer back to the original legislation or judicial proceeding when interpreting a codified law in order to understand the intent of the creator of the law.

The process of recodification

Recodification refers to the process of reformatting and rewriting existing codified statutes into a new codified structure. This process does not create new law, but merely arranges existing law into a code. For example, in the United States, acts of Congress are codified chronologically in the order in which they became law at Congress.gov. The United States Code, however, codifies federal statutes by subject matter. This process of recodification helps identify inconsistent, duplicate, and/or ambiguous laws, and creates a uniform source that is easy to access for both professionals and the lay public.

Over time, the legislative process of amending statutes and the legal process of construing statutes may require recodification. Recodification can involve taking judicial decisions or legislative acts and turning them into codified law. For example, in the preparation of the 1916 Code of Canon Law, centuries of material were examined, scrutinised for authenticity by leading experts, and harmonised as much as possible with opposing canons and other codes, from the Codex of Justinian to the Napoleonic Code. The new code contained 2,414 canons and was in force until 1983, when it was abrogated by the 1983 Code of Canon Law.

While codifications are useful for finding information, courts sometimes refer back to the original legislation or judicial proceeding when interpreting a codified law in order to understand the intent of the creator of the law.

Frequently asked questions