Missionary's Death: Law And Consequences

The murder of missionaries has sparked debates about the ethics of evangelism, cultural sensitivity, and the limits of religious freedom. John Allen Chau, a 26-year-old American missionary, was killed by an indigenous tribe on North Sentinel Island, an isolated island in the Indian Ocean, after attempting to convert them to Christianity. This incident has raised questions about whether Chau's actions were legal and culturally sensitive, especially as he disregarded local laws prohibiting outsiders from visiting the island. While some argue that his missionary work was important and brave, others believe that he was disrespectful and irresponsible. Similarly, in 1997, two Korean missionaries were tried for second-degree murder in the death of a woman during an exorcism ritual, highlighting the complex interplay between religion, culture, and the law. These cases demonstrate the potential consequences when religious beliefs and practices conflict with legal and cultural norms.

John Allen Chau's missionary work was illegal

Chau's missionary work was illegal under the Andaman and Nicobar Islands (Protection of Aboriginal Tribes) Regulation, 1956, which prohibits visiting North Sentinel Island without government permission. The Indian government maintains the isolation of the Sentinelese tribe to preserve their culture and protect them from lethal microbes that outsiders might introduce. Despite the risks, Chau paid two fishermen to take him near the island and then ventured closer in a kayak, disregarding local laws.

Chau's actions have sparked debate and controversy among Christians and missionaries. Some argue that his methods were unethical and irresponsible, particularly given the potential health risks to the Sentinelese tribe. Others defend his evangelical efforts and motivation to spread his religious faith.

Chau's work and death raise complex questions about the ethics of missionary work, the potential dangers to both missionaries and indigenous peoples, and the role of governments and international laws in protecting isolated communities.

North Sentinel Island is forbidden

The Sentinelese have a long history of resisting contact with outsiders. For centuries, they have violently repelled any attempts at intrusion, seeing outsiders as a threat to their protected isolation. This resistance is not without reason—the Sentinelese are at risk of contracting infectious diseases from outsiders, against which they have no immunity. As such, the Indian government has declared North Sentinel Island and its surrounding waters within a five-nautical-mile radius to be an exclusion zone, prohibiting travel to the island and restricting outsiders to remote monitoring from a safe distance.

Despite these protective measures, some individuals, like American missionary John Allen Chau, have attempted to make illegal contact with the Sentinelese. Chau, a 26-year-old Christian missionary, was killed by the Sentinelese in November 2018 after he made three separate illegal attempts to proselytise to the tribe. Chau's actions not only put himself in danger but also potentially exposed the Sentinelese to deadly pathogens.

The Sentinelese's voluntary isolation and their right to defend it must be respected. North Sentinel Island is forbidden for a reason—to protect a vulnerable tribe and their way of life from the potentially devastating impacts of outside interference.

John Chau was killed by the isolated tribe he was trying to convert

John Allen Chau was a 26-year-old American evangelical Christian missionary who was killed by the Sentinelese, a tribe in voluntary isolation, after illegally travelling to North Sentinel Island in an attempt to introduce the tribe to Christianity. Chau was killed and buried by the tribe of hunter-gatherers on a remote island in the Indian Ocean.

Chau had been preparing for this mission since he was about 18 years old. He had trained in linguistics and cultural anthropology, and had received 13 immunizations. He was also vaccinated and quarantined before his trip to North Sentinel Island. He was aware of the legal and mortal risks he was taking, writing in his diary: "Lord, is this island Satan's last stronghold, where none have heard or even had the chance to hear your name?" and "I think it's worthwhile to declare Jesus to these people. Please do not be angry at them or at God if I get killed... Don't retrieve my body."

Chau paid two fishermen to take him near the island. He then ventured closer in a kayak, disregarding local laws that prohibited outsiders from visiting the island. He shouted, "My name is John! I love you, and Jesus loves you. Jesus Christ gave me authority to come to you." He offered gifts to the tribe, but they responded with hostility. On another visit, a young man shot an arrow at him, which pierced his waterproof Bible but left him largely unscathed.

On his final visit, on November 17, 2018, Chau instructed the fishermen to abandon him. The fishermen later saw the islanders dragging Chau's body, and the next day they saw his body being buried on the shore. Despite efforts by Indian authorities, Chau's body was not recovered.

Chau's actions were controversial, even within Christian communities. Some considered him a martyr and a hero of the faith, while others criticised him for his reckless behaviour and for imposing his religious beliefs on an isolated tribe. His father, Dr Patrick Chau, blamed his son's death on the missionary community for inculcating an extreme Christian vision in Chau.

The Indian government maintains the isolation of the indigenous population of North Sentinel Island

The Sentinelese have a long history of resisting all contact with the outside world, often violently. As a result, the Indian government has implemented protective laws to maintain their isolation and minimise the risk of exposing the tribe to deadly diseases. The Andaman and Nicobar Islands (Protection of Aboriginal Tribes) Regulation, 1956, prohibits travel to the island and any approach closer than five nautical miles. The area is patrolled by the Indian Navy, which prevents visitors from landing. The Indian government also does not prosecute the Sentinelese for killing people who venture onto the island.

The Sentinelese's isolation is also due to the island's geography. North Sentinel Island is small, surrounded by a shallow reef with no natural harbours, and located off the main shipping routes. This makes it difficult for outsiders to access.

Despite the Indian government's efforts, there have been several instances of unauthorised visits to the island, including by American missionary John Chau in 2018, who was killed by the Sentinelese. The Indian government has called off attempts to recover Chau's body, citing the risk of confrontation with the tribe.

The Sentinelese's isolation is important to protect their culture and way of life, as well as their physical health. Their isolation has allowed them to maintain their traditional lifestyle, which includes hunting and gathering, and living in small, temporary huts. They have also been able to avoid exposure to deadly diseases, which could have devastating effects on their small community.

In conclusion, the Indian government's policies and enforcement play a crucial role in maintaining the isolation of the Sentinelese tribe on North Sentinel Island. This isolation is important to protect their culture, traditions, and physical health. While there have been some unauthorised visits to the island, the Indian government's overall efforts have been successful in maintaining the tribe's isolation.

Five fishermen who helped John Chau travel to North Sentinel Island have been arrested

Chau hired local fishermen to take him near the island and then ventured closer in a kayak, disregarding local laws that prohibited outsiders from visiting. The fishermen who helped Chau were granted bail by a court in Port Blair, Andaman, an island territory of India, on December 19, 2018. They were arrested under various charges, including culpable homicide, conveying a person by water for hire in an unsafe vessel, endangering human life, and breaking various laws meant to protect aboriginal tribes.

In total, seven people, including the five fishermen, were arrested for helping Chau reach the island. The other two individuals arrested were a local friend of Chau's, named Alexander, and a local water sports helper named Saw Remmis. Chau reportedly paid the fishermen Rs. 25,000, or about $70 each.

The fishermen claimed that they anchored their boat about 500 meters from the beach and that Chau rowed a canoe to shore, even as arrows were shot in his direction. Chau returned to the boat later that day with some injuries from the arrows but stated in his journal that he wanted to go back to the island. He left his journal with the fishermen, which described how the tribal men reacted angrily when he tried to sing worship songs.

Chau's actions have sparked debate over the ethics of missionary work and the potential consequences for both the missionaries and the indigenous people they attempt to contact.

Frequently asked questions