Labor Laws And Churches: California's Unique Religious Exemption

Religious organizations and churches are generally exempt from the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) in the United States. However, this does not mean that they are exempt from all labor laws. While churches have the right to choose their religious leaders without government interference, they must comply with federal employment laws for other employees. This includes complying with laws such as Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Family and Medical Leave Act, and the Age Discrimination in Employment Act. Furthermore, the applicability of the FLSA to church employees depends on the nature of their work and whether it involves interstate commerce.

Do religious leaders count as employees?

Religious institutions in California are subject to a variety of federal employment laws, including the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration Act of 1970 (OSHA), the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), the Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 (FMLA), the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA), and the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). However, the applicability of these laws depends on the number of employees and the nature of the religious organization's activities.

Now, do religious leaders count as employees? The answer is not straightforward and depends on various factors. In the context of labor laws, there is a concept called the ""Ministerial Exemption." This means that religious institutions have the freedom to choose and dismiss their religious leaders without worrying about federal labor laws. These "ministerial employees" are typically individuals who have received formalized religious education and have been designated as spiritual leaders by the religious group. Their role primarily involves giving spiritual guidance and religious education to the members of the religious organization.

While priests, rabbis, imams, preachers, and reverends are typically considered ministerial employees due to their clergy status, the classification of other employees in a religious institution is more complex. For example, in the case of Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church & School v. EEOC, the Supreme Court ruled that a teacher at a church school who had undergone formal religious training and was chosen as a leader by the congregants was considered a ministerial employee, even though she was not part of the clergy.

The determination of whether an employee qualifies as a ministerial employee is not always clear-cut. However, factors such as formalized religious education and designation as a spiritual leader by the religious group are considered. Additionally, the title of the position is not solely determinative but may be relevant. It is important to note that office and janitorial staff are typically fully protected by federal labor laws, while positions like choir director or education director may fall under the ministerial exemption.

Do religious institutions have to follow federal labour laws?

Religious institutions in the United States are subject to some federal labour laws, but there are exemptions for certain employees and activities.

The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) sets minimum wages and requires most workers to be paid for all hours worked, as well as overtime for hours worked beyond 40 per week. While religious organisations and churches are generally exempt from the FLSA, they must comply with the law when operating commercial businesses, such as gas stations, retail outlets, or grocery stores. These commercial activities must generate at least $500,000 in annual revenue to be considered an "enterprise" under the FLSA.

The FLSA also covers employees of religious institutions who are engaged in interstate commerce, such as through the use of interstate communications tools like mail, telephone, or the internet. This means that employees like administrative assistants or custodians who communicate with out-of-state individuals or order supplies from other states are likely covered by the FLSA.

Additionally, religious institutions must comply with federal employment laws that prohibit discrimination, such as Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits discrimination based on race, colour, sex, religion, or national origin. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) also applies to religious institutions, prohibiting discrimination based on disability.

However, there is a ministerial exemption that allows religious institutions to treat ministers and spiritual leaders differently when it comes to employment decisions. This exemption gives religious institutions the right to choose and fire their religious leaders without worrying about federal labour laws. The exact scope of this exemption is complex and subject to legal interpretation, as there is no clear definition of who qualifies as a ministerial employee.

Overall, while religious institutions must comply with certain federal labour laws, there are exemptions and complexities that arise from the intersection of employment law and the First Amendment right to freely exercise religion.

What is the 'Ministerial Exemption'?

The Ministerial Exemption, also known as the Ministerial Exception, is a legal doctrine in the United States that protects religious institutions from government interference in their employment decisions for ministers or those with ministerial roles. It is rooted in the First Amendment, specifically the Free Exercise Clause and the Establishment Clause, which safeguard the freedom of religious groups to select their leaders and prevent government involvement in ecclesiastical decisions, respectively.

The Ministerial Exemption was first applied in the 1972 case of McClure v. Salvation Army, where the Fifth Circuit found that an employee could not sue the Salvation Army for violations under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. The court reasoned that allowing such suits would result in government encroachment on religious freedom, in violation of the First Amendment. This set a precedent for future cases involving religious institutions and their employment decisions.

The Supreme Court affirmed the Ministerial Exemption in the 2012 case of Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church and School v. E.E.O.C. In this case, the Court upheld the right of religious institutions to make employment decisions for ministers without government interference, based on both the Free Exercise and Establishment Clauses of the First Amendment. The Court declined to adopt a rigid formula for determining who qualifies as a minister but cited four relevant factors in the Hosanna-Tabor case:

• The employee was held out as a minister and given a formal ministerial title.
• The employee underwent a significant degree of religious training to obtain that title.
• The employee held themselves out as a minister, even claiming special housing allowances for ministers on their taxes.
• The employee performed significant religious functions, including playing a role in conveying the Church's message and carrying out its mission.

The Ministerial Exemption gives religious institutions an affirmative defense against lawsuits for discrimination. For example, a woman seeking to become a Catholic priest cannot sue the Catholic Church for sex discrimination over its stance that women cannot be ordained as priests. However, the exemption does not permit religious organizations to ignore all non-discrimination requirements. They must demonstrate that their employment decisions are based on the organization's fundamental religious beliefs and not on prejudice or convenience.

While the Ministerial Exemption provides religious institutions with significant autonomy in selecting their leaders, it does not apply to all employees. Many positions in a religious organization, even in a house of worship or seminary, may not be considered "ministerial." These employees are still protected by federal employment laws, and religious organizations must comply with non-discrimination requirements in their hiring and employment practices for these roles.

Do churches have to post workplace posters?

Whether or not a church must follow federal labor laws depends on who the employee is. While churches have the absolute right to choose their religious leaders without government interference, they must abide by federal employment laws for all other employees.

If a church has at least one paid employee, it is required to post some workplace posters. The specific posters that need to be displayed depend on the number of employees and whether the church is engaged in commerce.

Churches with 15 or more employees must abide by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits employers from discriminating against or harassing employees and potential employees on the basis of race, color, sex, religion, or national origin.

Churches with 15 or more employees must also comply with the Occupational Safety and Health Administration Act of 1970 (OSHA), which ensures safe and healthy working conditions.

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), which prohibits discrimination based on disability, applies to churches with 15 or more employees.

The Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 (FMLA) provides for unpaid, job-protected leave for specific family and medical reasons and applies to churches with 50 or more employees.

The Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) prohibits discrimination based on age against people over 40 and applies to churches with 20 or more employees.

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA), also known as "Obamacare," requires employers with a certain number of employees to provide nondiscriminatory healthcare benefits. This applies to churches with 50 or more employees who can be categorized as "full-time equivalents," defined as working at least 30 hours per week.

The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) establishes minimum wage and overtime pay standards affecting all workers, including full and part-time workers. However, the FLSA does not apply to churches that derive no financial benefit from commercial activity and do not have employees engaged in interstate commerce.

While there are no significant fines or penalties for churches that fail to display the required workplace posters, it is still recommended to comply with the applicable poster requirements. Failure to do so may extend the time employees have to file discrimination claims, potentially exposing the church to liability for a more extended period.

Churches can obtain free copies of the required posters from local offices of the United States Department of Labor or by visiting the DOL website. However, it is important to note that some modifications may be necessary to avoid confusion, as the official posters do not always address the unique status of ministers and churches under certain laws.

Do churches have to comply with the Fair Labour Standards Act?

Whether or not churches have to comply with the Fair Labour Standards Act (FLSA) is a complex question that depends on several factors. Firstly, the FLSA establishes minimum wage, overtime pay, and other labour standards for workers, including both full and part-time workers. It applies to employees of covered "enterprises" and those individually engaged in interstate commerce.

The FLSA does not apply to churches that do not derive financial benefit from commercial activity and do not have employees engaged in interstate commerce. The federal government generally does not consider churches to be "enterprises" as employees are not performing a "business purpose". However, individual employees of a church may still be covered by the FLSA under "Individual Coverage" if they are engaged in interstate commerce on a "regular and recurrent" basis. This includes activities such as interstate telephone calls, interstate mail, and ordering or receiving materials across state lines.

In summary, while churches as institutions may not always be subject to the FLSA, individual employees within a church may still be covered by the Act if they meet the criteria for "Individual Coverage". Therefore, it is important for churches to seek legal counsel to determine their specific situation and ensure compliance with applicable labour laws.

Frequently asked questions