Sunshine Laws: Private Citizens' Rights And Responsibilities

Sunshine laws are regulations that require government entities and businesses to maintain public transparency in their dealings. They mandate that official actions undertaken by businesses or government entities must be made available for public observation, participation, or inspection. These laws are intended to hold government authorities and businesses accountable to the populations they serve.

section break

But do sunshine laws apply to private citizens?

Sunshine laws and the Freedom of Information Act

Sunshine laws are regulations that require government entities and businesses to maintain public transparency in their dealings. They require specific businesses and government agencies to be transparent and disclose their activities to the public. This includes making meetings, records, votes, deliberations, and other official actions available for public observation, participation, or inspection.

The Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) is a classic example of a sunshine law. It protects a citizen's right to request certain information from the federal government. Not all information must be disclosed through FOIA, such as that pertaining to national security, certain aspects of law enforcement, trade secrets, or privileged communications.

Sunshine laws also apply to the medical field, where pharmaceutical companies and manufacturers are required to disclose what items have been provided to an institution or physician, along with the associated value, as part of their standard reporting procedure.

Sunshine laws can be enacted at the state or federal level, and they vary from state to state in terms of their specific mandates. All 50 US states have enacted some form of open meeting law for their local and state governing bodies.

The purpose of sunshine laws is to promote ethical standards, prevent fraud and corruption, and increase public trust. They are designed to hold government authorities and businesses accountable to the populations they serve.

Sunshine laws and the Government in the Sunshine Act

Sunshine laws are regulations that require government entities and businesses to maintain public transparency in their dealings. The Government in the Sunshine Act (Pub. L. 94–409, 90 Stat. 1241, enacted September 13, 1976, 5 U.S.C. § 552b) is a US federal law that affects the operations of the federal government, Congress, federal commissions, and other legally constituted federal bodies. The Act requires that "every portion of every meeting of an agency shall be open to public observation".

The Act defines a "meeting" as "the deliberations of at least the number of individual agency members required to take action on behalf of the agency where such deliberations determine or result in the joint conduct or disposition of official agency business". It defines an "agency" as any agency headed by a collegial body composed of two or more individual members and any subdivision thereof authorized to act on behalf of the agency.

The Act provides ten specified exemptions to the openness requirement, including information relating to national defense, internal personnel rules, matters protected by law, trade secrets, matters censuring or accusing a person of a crime, information that would breach privacy, investigatory records that would harm proceedings, information related to financial institutions, information that would lead to financial speculation or endanger financial stability, and information related to the agency's participation in legal proceedings.

The Sunshine Act was driven in part by the Watergate political scandal and increased demands for federal government accountability to its citizens. It is one of a number of Freedom of Information Acts, intended to create greater transparency in government and promote ethical standards, prevent fraud and corruption, and engender greater public trust.

Sunshine laws vary from state to state in the US, but all 50 states have enacted some form of open meeting law for their local and state governing bodies. For example, Florida's Government-in-the-Sunshine Law applies to any board or commission of any state agency or authority or of any agency or authority of any county, municipal corporation, or political subdivision. It requires that meetings of boards or commissions must be open to the public, that reasonable notice of such meetings must be given, and that minutes of the meeting must be taken.

Sunshine laws also apply to businesses, often in relation to financial reporting to bodies like the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). In the medical field, sunshine laws require certain manufacturers, such as pharmaceutical companies, to disclose what items have been provided to an institution or physician, along with the associated value of the items.

Sunshine laws and the medical field

Sunshine laws are regulations that require government entities and businesses to maintain public transparency in their dealings. They are designed to hold government authorities and businesses accountable to the populations they serve and protect consumers from unethical practices. Sunshine laws can be enacted at the state or federal level.

In the medical field, sunshine laws require manufacturers, such as pharmaceutical companies, to disclose what items have been provided to an institution or physician, along with the associated value of the items. This is done as part of a standard reporting procedure. This is to improve the transparency surrounding the financial ramifications of such transactions, making the information accessible and trackable.

The Physician Payments Sunshine Act is a federal law designed to increase transparency around the financial relationships between physicians, teaching hospitals, and manufacturers of drugs, medical devices, and biologics. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) fulfill the law's mandate via the Open Payments Program. Manufacturers must now submit annual data on payments and transfers of value made to covered recipients. Physicians have 45 days to review their Open Payments data and dispute errors before public release.

Sunshine laws in the medical field also require pharmaceutical companies and other major corporate players to disclose certain information as part of their regular reporting and operating procedures. This helps to ensure that the public can view actions and hold companies to ethical standards.

Sunshine laws and the private sector

Sunshine laws are regulations that require government entities and businesses to maintain public transparency in their dealings. They mandate that official actions undertaken by businesses or government entities must be made available for public observation, participation, or inspection. They also require government organizations to provide sufficient notice before public meetings and hold those meetings in a convenient, accessible location.

The federal sunshine law mandate can be traced back to 1976’s Government in the Sunshine Act, driven in part by the recent Watergate political scandal and increased demand to hold the federal government accountable to its citizens. However, this wasn’t the first sunshine law on record – California’s state sunshine law (The Brown Act) actually predates the federal mandate, enacted in 1953.

Sunshine laws vary from state to state in terms of their specific mandates, but all 50 U.S. states have enacted some form of open meeting law for their local and state governing bodies. For example, sunshine laws in government generally relate to open meeting policies and ensuring that information is put into the public record. On the other hand, sunshine laws for businesses more often relate to financial reporting to bodies like the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

While the language of sunshine laws is meant to minimize exceptions, there are a few instances protected from sunshine laws. Most notably, sunshine law reporting may not apply in the following scenarios:

• Active legal proceedings and certain aspects of law enforcement
• Issues pertaining to national security
• Certain commercial or financial trade secrets
• Communications considered protected or “privileged”
• Information that would lead to financial speculation or otherwise damage a company’s stability
• Certain disciplinary actions that may violate personal privacy

Sunshine laws are a consumer protection mandate meant to hold entities to a higher standard of transparency, ethical practices, and accountability. They bring visibility to practices and help foster an open business environment built on trust.

Sunshine laws and the public

Sunshine laws are regulations that require government entities and businesses to maintain public transparency in their dealings. They are designed to hold government authorities and businesses accountable to the populations they serve.

The Purpose of Sunshine Laws

The primary objective of sunshine laws is to promote accountability and prevent fraud, corruption, and inequality within government agencies and businesses. They are intended to ensure ethical practices and increase public trust by allowing members of the public to bear witness to certain activities or request access to records.

History of Sunshine Laws

The concept of sunshine laws can be traced back to the Government in the Sunshine Act, passed in 1976 in the United States. This federal mandate was driven by the Watergate political scandal and the desire to hold the federal government accountable to its citizens. However, California's state sunshine law, known as The Brown Act, predates the federal law, having been enacted in 1953.

Scope of Sunshine Laws

Sunshine laws vary from state to state in the US, but all 50 states have enacted some form of open meeting law for their local and state governing bodies. These laws apply to a wide range of entities, including federal and state agencies, local governments, educational institutions, licensing bodies, and various committees and subordinate groups.

Exceptions to Sunshine Laws

While sunshine laws aim to minimize exceptions, there are certain scenarios where they may not apply. These include active legal proceedings, issues of national security, trade secrets, privileged communications, and situations involving personal privacy. Additionally, advisory committees or boards that lack the authority to create binding laws may not be subject to sunshine laws.

Sunshine Laws in Practice

Sunshine laws have a direct impact on the public by promoting transparency and providing access to information. For example, citizens can request certain information about themselves collected by the federal government through the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). Sunshine laws also apply to specific sectors, such as the medical field, where manufacturers are required to disclose items and their values provided to institutions.

In summary, sunshine laws are an essential tool for ensuring transparency and accountability in government and business dealings, empowering citizens with access to information and fostering greater public trust.

Frequently asked questions