Can A President Be Impeached Without Breaking The Law?

Impeachment is a process by which a legislative body or other legally constituted tribunal initiates charges against a public official for misconduct. In the United States, impeachment at the federal level is limited to those who may have committed treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors. The House of Representatives has the sole power of impeachment, while the Senate has the sole power to try impeachments. The Senate can vote by a 2/3 majority to convict an official, removing them from office. But does a president have to break the law to be impeached?

What is impeachment?

Impeachment is a process by which a legislative body or other legally constituted tribunal initiates charges against a public official for misconduct. It is a unique process involving both political and legal elements.

In the United States, impeachment is the process by which a legislature may bring charges against an officeholder for misconduct, with the penalty of removal. The federal House of Representatives can impeach a party with a simple majority of the House members present. This triggers a federal impeachment trial in the United States Senate, which can vote by a 2/3 majority to convict an official, removing them from office. The Senate can also vote with a simple majority to bar an individual convicted in a senate impeachment trial from holding future federal office.

The Constitution gives Congress the authority to impeach and remove "The President, Vice President, and all civil Officers of the United States" upon a determination that such officers have engaged in treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors. The House of Representatives has the sole power of impeachment, while the Senate has the sole power to try impeachments (i.e., to acquit or convict). The validity of an impeachment trial is a political question that is nonjusticiable (i.e., not reviewable by the courts).

Impeachment proceedings are remedial rather than punitive in nature, and the remedy is limited to removal from office. Because the process is not punitive, a party may also be subject to criminal or civil trial, prosecution, and conviction under the law after removal from office. Also, because the conviction is not a punishment, the president of the United States is constitutionally precluded from granting a pardon to impeached and convicted persons that would protect them from the consequences of a conviction in an impeachment trial.

At the federal level, the impeachment process typically involves three steps: an impeachment inquiry, impeachment by the House of Representatives, and a trial by the United States Senate. The House investigates through an impeachment inquiry, then must pass articles of impeachment by a simple majority of those present and voting. Upon passage, the defendant has been "impeached". The Senate then tries the accused, with the chief justice of the United States presiding over the proceedings in the case of a presidential impeachment trial. Conviction in the Senate requires the concurrence of a two-thirds supermajority of those present. The result of conviction is removal from office and (optionally, in a separate vote) disqualification from holding any federal office in the future, which requires a concurrence of only a majority of senators present.

In the United States, impeachment at the federal level is limited to those who may have committed "Treason, Bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors", with the latter referring to offenses against the government or the constitution, grave abuses of power, violations of the public trust, or other political crimes, even if not indictable criminal offenses.

Who can be impeached?

Impeachment is a process that can be applied to a wide range of public officials, including the President, Vice President, federal judges, cabinet secretaries, and senators. It is a mechanism to hold government officials accountable for any wrongdoing, abuse of power, or violation of the law.

In the United States, the power to impeach lies with the House of Representatives, which can initiate impeachment proceedings against any federal official. The Senate then conducts the impeachment trial and decides whether to convict and remove the official from their position.

The Constitution specifies that impeachment is applicable to "The President, Vice President, and all civil Officers of the United States." This includes any presidentially appointed "principal officer," such as the head of an agency or a Secretary.

Additionally, impeachment can occur at the state and local levels of government. Most state legislatures have the power to impeach state officials, including governors, and some local governments also have impeachment procedures in place.

Impeachment is a serious process that is reserved for those who have committed serious abuses of their office or violated the public trust. It is an essential tool in the system of checks and balances, ensuring that government officials are held accountable for their actions.

What are the criteria for impeachment?

Impeachment is a process by which a legislative body or other legally constituted tribunal initiates charges against a public official for misconduct. In the United States, impeachment at the federal level is limited to those who may have committed "treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanours". The latter phrase refers to offences against the government or the constitution, grave abuses of power, violations of the public trust, or other political crimes, even if not indictable criminal offences.

The Constitution gives Congress the authority to impeach and remove "The President, Vice President, and all civil Officers of the United States" upon a determination that such officers have engaged in the aforementioned acts. The Constitution does not articulate who qualifies as a "civil officer of the United States". Federal judges are subject to impeachment. Within the executive branch, any presidentially appointed "principal officer", including a head of an agency such as a Secretary, Administrator, or Commissioner, is a "civil officer of the United States" subject to impeachment. At the opposite end of the spectrum, lesser functionaries, such as federal civil service employees, do not exercise "significant authority" and are therefore not subject to impeachment.

The House of Representatives brings articles (charges) of impeachment against an official. If the House adopts the articles by a simple majority vote, the official has been impeached. The Senate holds an impeachment trial. In the case of a president, the U.S. Supreme Court chief justice presides. If found guilty, the official is removed from office. They may never be able to hold elected office again. If they are not found guilty, they may continue to serve in office.

What is the process of impeachment?

The impeachment process is a fundamental component of the system of checks and balances. It involves bringing charges against a sitting member of the government, including the President, Vice President, and other federal civil officers. Impeachable offences are outlined in the Constitution as "treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors".

The process can be broken down into three steps:

• An investigation in House of Representatives committees: The House of Representatives investigates through an impeachment inquiry. This is not a required stage, but it is the first phase in most cases.
• A vote of the House to pass articles of impeachment: The House of Representatives must pass, by a simple majority of those present and voting, articles of impeachment, which constitute the formal allegation or allegations. Upon passage, the defendant has been "impeached".
• A trial and vote in the Senate to convict the official: The Senate tries the accused. In the case of the impeachment of a president, the chief justice of the United States presides over the proceedings. Conviction in the Senate requires the concurrence of a two-thirds supermajority of those present. The result of conviction is removal from office and (optionally, in a separate vote) disqualification from holding any federal office in the future, which requires a concurrence of only a majority of senators present.

Can a president be impeached more than once?

In the United States, impeachment is the process by which a legislature may bring charges against an officeholder for misconduct. The House of Representatives can impeach a party with a simple majority of the House members present. This triggers a federal impeachment trial in the United States Senate, which can vote by a 2/3 majority to convict an official, removing them from office. The Senate can also vote with a simple majority to bar an individual from holding future federal office.

The Constitution gives Congress the authority to impeach and remove "The President, Vice President, and all civil Officers of the United States" upon a determination that such officers have engaged in treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors. The Constitution does not articulate who qualifies as a "civil officer of the United States". Federal judges are subject to impeachment. Within the executive branch, any "principal officer" appointed by the president, including a head of an agency, is a "civil officer of the United States" subject to impeachment.

The Constitution does not limit the number of times an individual may be impeached. As of January 2024, Donald Trump is the only federal officer to have been impeached more than once. Trump was impeached by the House in 2019 and 2021.

At the federal level, the impeachment process is typically a three-step procedure. The first phase is typically an impeachment inquiry, though this is not a required stage. The two stages constitutionally required for removal are impeachment by the House of Representatives and trial by the United States Senate.

Frequently asked questions