Lemon Law And Leased Vehicles: What You Need To Know

Lemon laws are designed to protect consumers who buy or lease a defective vehicle, otherwise known as a lemon. Lemon laws apply to leased vehicles in California and most, if not all, other states. In New York, for example, the Lemon Law applies to leased vehicles as long as they were covered by the manufacturer's new car warranty when purchased, leased or registered in New York, and used mainly for personal reasons.

Lemon law and leased vehicles in New York

The New York Lemon Law offers protection to those who buy or lease a new car that turns out to be a "lemon", defined as a car that doesn't conform to the terms of the written warranty and cannot be repaired by the manufacturer or its authorized dealer after a reasonable number of attempts.

The law covers new cars and some used cars, including demonstrators and motorcycles, that meet the following conditions:

• Covered by the manufacturer's express warranty at the time of original delivery.
• Purchased, leased, or transferred within the first 18,000 miles of operation or two years from the date of original delivery, whichever is earlier.
• Purchased, leased, or transferred in New York State, or presently registered in the state.
• Used primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.

The New York Lemon Law covers any nonconformity, defect, or condition covered under the manufacturer's warranty that substantially impairs the value of the vehicle to the consumer. The law does not cover problems that are the result of abuse, neglect, or unauthorized modifications or alterations.

The Manufacturer's Duty to Repair

With respect to covered vehicles sold and registered in New York, the manufacturer has a duty to repair, free of charge and without any deductible, any defect covered by warranty if the consumer notifies the manufacturer or its authorized dealer within the first 18,000 miles of operation or two years from the original delivery date, whichever comes first. The manufacturer, its agent, or authorized dealer must correct the nonconformity at no charge to the consumer, even if the 18,000-mile/two-year period has expired.

The New York Lemon Law presumes a reasonable number of repair attempts if either of the following occurs:

• The same nonconformity has been subject to repair four or more times, but the problem continues to exist.
• The vehicle is out of service for a cumulative total of 30 or more calendar days due to repairs.

The Manufacturer's Duty to Replace or Repurchase the Vehicle

If repairs cannot be made, the manufacturer must either replace the vehicle or repurchase it at the consumer's choice. If the consumer elects to receive a replacement, they are entitled to a comparable vehicle of the same year and model with similar mileage. If the consumer chooses to get a refund, the manufacturer must pay the full purchase price, fees, and charges, minus a mileage allowance for miles exceeding 12,000 and a reasonable allowance for any damage not attributable to normal wear and tear or improvements.

Lemon law and leased vehicles in California

Leasing a car in California is a popular option for many consumers. It allows them to drive a new, reliable vehicle without the long-term commitment of ownership. However, what happens if your leased car turns out to be a lemon?

The good news is that California's Lemon Law does apply to leased vehicles. This means that lessees in California have specific rights and protections under the law if they find themselves stuck with a defective vehicle.

A lemon is a vehicle with significant issues or defects that impair its safety, value, or use. These issues must be substantial and persistent, and the manufacturer must be unable to provide a permanent fix after a reasonable number of repair attempts.

Qualifying for Lemon Law Protection in California

To qualify for lemon law protection for your leased vehicle in California, certain conditions must generally be met:

• The issues must be substantial and persistent, impairing the vehicle's use, safety, or value.
• There must have been multiple repair attempts (usually 3-4 for non-safety issues or 2 for safety issues) without resolution.
• The defects must be covered under the manufacturer's warranty.

Steps to Take if Your Leased Vehicle is a Lemon in California

If you suspect your leased vehicle is a lemon, here are the steps you can take:

• Keep detailed records of all repairs, communications, and issues with your leased vehicle.
• Notify the manufacturer or dealer of the persistent issues in writing and provide them with all the necessary documentation.
• Consult with an experienced California lemon law attorney who can guide you through the legal process and negotiate with the manufacturer.
• File a lemon law claim by notifying the manufacturer in writing and providing them with a formal notice and supporting evidence.
• Negotiate or litigate: The manufacturer may offer a settlement, such as repurchasing or replacing your vehicle. If a fair agreement cannot be reached, you may need to pursue litigation and take your case to court.

Benefits of Lemon Law Relief for Leased Vehicles in California

Obtaining lemon law relief for your leased vehicle in California offers several advantages:

• You may receive compensation or a replacement vehicle, relieving you of the burden of driving a defective car.
• You hold the manufacturer accountable for producing a defective vehicle and protect your consumer rights.
• You may receive a refund for almost all of your lease payments, along with legal costs and other related expenses.

What to do if your leased vehicle is a lemon

Lemon laws apply to leased vehicles in the United States, including in California and New York. If you've leased a vehicle that turns out to be a lemon, here are some steps you can take to protect yourself and seek remedies:

• Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all issues, complaints, repair attempts, work orders, repair bills, and correspondence related to the vehicle. This documentation will be crucial if you need to pursue legal action.
• Notify the Manufacturer or Dealer: Immediately report any defects or issues directly to the manufacturer or authorised dealer. If you notify the dealer, they are typically required to forward the information to the manufacturer within a specified timeframe.
• Understand Lemon Laws in Your State: Lemon laws vary by state, so it's important to understand the specific laws in your state. Look up the lemon laws in your state to know your rights and the process for making a claim.
• Seek Legal Advice: Consult with a lawyer who specialises in lemon law. They can guide you through the process, help you gather the necessary documentation, and represent you in any legal proceedings.
• Take the Vehicle for Service: Take your leased vehicle for maintenance and repairs to an authorised dealer or service centre. Failing to do so could affect your eligibility for lemon law protection.
• Know the Requirements: To qualify for protection under lemon laws, certain requirements typically need to be met. These may include the vehicle being under warranty, the issues arising within a certain timeframe or mileage threshold, and the manufacturer or dealer being unable to repair the issues after a reasonable number of attempts.
• Request Arbitration or File a Claim: If your vehicle meets the requirements for a lemon law claim, you can initiate the process by requesting arbitration or filing a claim. This process may vary depending on your state, but it typically involves submitting the necessary documentation and providing evidence of the issues with your vehicle.

Remember, it's important to act promptly if you believe you have a lemon. Consult with a specialised lawyer to understand your specific rights and options, as they can guide you through the process and help you seek the remedies you are entitled to.

How to prove your leased vehicle is a lemon

Lemon laws apply to both leased and purchased vehicles, although the exact specifications vary depending on the state. Here are some steps to prove that your leased vehicle is a lemon:

Manufacturer's Warranty

Firstly, for lemon laws to be applicable, the leased vehicle must be under its original manufacturer's warranty. This warranty ensures that any defects are the manufacturer's responsibility and not due to wear and tear or external factors.

Document Defects and Repair Attempts

Thoroughly document all repair details, including dates, issues, and actions taken by the dealership or manufacturer. This documentation will serve as vital evidence for potential legal action. Keep a meticulous record of all interactions, repair attempts, and communications with the authorized dealership. Whenever possible, engage in written correspondence with the manufacturer or dealer to establish a documented trail that can support your case.

Persistent Defects

The crux of lemon laws is the presence of a defect that persists despite multiple repair attempts. For instance, if your vehicle consistently experiences the same issue, such as a battery or brake problem, and it remains unresolved, this persistent defect is key to qualifying your vehicle as a 'lemon'.

Safety, Value, or Usability Impairment

To be considered a 'lemon', the defects in the vehicle must substantially impair its safety, value, or usability. These could range from serious issues like transmission problems to minor glitches in the infotainment system.

Number of Repair Attempts

The number of repair attempts required varies by state. Generally, if your leased vehicle has been in the repair shop multiple times for the same issue or has been unusable for an extended period, it could be protected under lemon laws. For example, in New York, a reasonable number of repair attempts is considered to be four or more visits to the dealership for the same problem or a total of 30 or more cumulative days out of service.

Consult a Lemon Law Attorney

If significant defects persist despite multiple repair attempts, seek guidance from a legal expert specializing in lemon law. They can help you navigate the process and facilitate the attainment of rightful compensation.

What to do if your leased vehicle is spending a lot of time in the service department

If your leased vehicle is spending a lot of time in the service department, it's important to understand your rights and take the necessary steps to protect yourself. Here's what you should do:

Understand Lemon Laws:

Lemon laws vary by state, but in most states, including California, lemon laws apply to both leased and purchased vehicles. Lemon laws provide legal protection if your leased vehicle turns out to be defective. The standard for determining whether your leased car is a lemon is whether the vehicle's use, value, or safety is substantially impaired by the defect. These defects could range from serious transmission issues to minor problems like a glitchy infotainment system.

Document Repair Attempts:

For lemon laws to apply, you must give the manufacturer or its authorized agent, typically through dealership service centers, the opportunity to fix the defects. The number of repair attempts required depends on the severity of the issues and the state you reside in. For safety-related issues, you usually need at least two documented service attempts for the same problem. For non-safety issues, you may need at least four documented service attempts. Keep careful records of all repair attempts, work orders, and correspondence.

Meet Other Requirements:

In addition to repair attempts, there are other requirements that must be met for lemon law protection. These may include the vehicle being covered by a warranty, the problem arising within a certain timeframe or mileage threshold (such as within two years or 18,000 miles), and the vehicle being used primarily for personal purposes. Make sure to review the specific lemon laws in your state.

Contact the Manufacturer:

If you believe your leased vehicle meets the criteria for a lemon, immediately report any defects directly to the manufacturer or its authorized dealer. The dealer is then required to forward written notice to the manufacturer within a specified timeframe, such as seven days. It is important to act promptly and keep detailed records of all communications.

Seek Legal Advice:

Consult a lemon law attorney to understand your rights and options. An experienced lawyer can guide you through the process, help you build a strong case, and ensure your interests are protected. They can also advise you on whether you may qualify for a refund, replacement vehicle, or other compensation. Lemon laws in some states, like New York, provide for fee-shifting provisions, meaning the manufacturer may be responsible for your attorney fees and legal expenses if your claim is successful.

Frequently asked questions