Challenging Texas Abortion Law: Strategies For Change

Texas has some of the most restrictive abortion laws in the US. The state bans abortion at all stages of pregnancy, without exceptions for rape or incest, and with limited exemptions for pregnant people at risk of death. This includes Senate Bill 8 (SB 8), which took effect on 1 September 2021, outlawing abortion after six weeks of gestation. The law also allows private citizens to sue anyone who helps a woman get an abortion. Several legal challenges have been brought against these laws, with abortion rights groups arguing that they are an aggressive expansion of state regulation of abortion.

ACLU of Texas is challenging the validity of pre-Roe statutes

The ACLU of Texas is challenging the validity of pre-Roe statutes in court, alongside other partners. On June 28, 2022, a judge in Harris County sided with abortion providers and issued a temporary restraining order, blocking any prosecutions under the pre-Roe statutes.

The pre-Roe statutes refer to the state of Texas' position that the criminal laws at issue in Roe v. Wade remain in effect. These laws prohibit abortion at all stages of pregnancy with limited exceptions. However, legally, these laws are inconsistent with due process guarantees in the Texas constitution and have been interpreted as repealed and unenforceable.

The ACLU of Texas is arguing that the pre-Roe statutes are antiquated and should not be enforced. They are seeking to block officials from enforcing these laws, which would restore early abortion access in Texas for a limited time. The ACLU's efforts are focused on extending care for people in Texas and ensuring bodily autonomy for Texans.

The ACLU's lawsuit is a direct response to the Texas Attorney General's advisory, which stated that abortion providers could be criminally liable for providing abortions based on the state's abortion prohibitions predating Roe v. Wade. The Attorney General, Ken Paxton, does not have the authority to prosecute criminal violations but sought emergency relief from the Texas Supreme Court, which was granted.

Texas' abortion law allows citizens to sue abortion providers

Texas' abortion law, Senate Bill 8 (SB 8), allows citizens to sue abortion providers and anyone who helps a woman get an abortion for a minimum of $10,000. This law is designed to circumvent the judiciary and make it harder for abortion providers and abortion rights activists to challenge it in court. The law does not provide exceptions for rape or incest and bans abortion once a fetal heartbeat is detected, which can be as early as six weeks into a pregnancy.

The law has raised concerns among abortion rights advocates and medical professionals, who worry that it will lead to a wave of harassing lawsuits and create a "chilling effect" on abortion providers. They argue that the law is unconstitutional and creates an "unprecedented" change to Texas' courts. In addition to medical professionals, anyone who provides logistical or emotional support to a woman seeking an abortion, including family members, clergy, and rape crisis counselors, can be sued under this law.

The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and the American Medical Association oppose Texas' abortion laws because they believe excessive restrictions on abortion care jeopardize patients' health. As a result of these laws, there are not enough abortion clinics to serve people in Texas, the nation's second-most populous state. About 900,000 people of reproductive age in Texas live more than 150 miles from the nearest abortion clinic.

The law also has implications for insurance coverage and employment. As of December 1, 2017, Texas law forbids insurers from covering abortion as part of a person's overall health insurance plan unless the procedure is necessary to save the person from death or serious physical injury. Military insurance and Medicaid only cover abortion in cases of rape, incest, or life-threatening conditions. Additionally, employers who help their workers get abortions could be punished under proposed legislation.

Despite the challenges, abortion rights activists and providers are exploring all legal options to prevent the law from taking effect and continue providing care to those who need it. The ACLU of Texas and partners are challenging the validity of the pre-Roe statutes in the courts and have had some success in blocking prosecutions under these laws.

Texas' abortion law allows citizens to sue anyone who helps a woman get an abortion

Texas's abortion law, Senate Bill 8 (SB 8), allows citizens to sue anyone who helps a woman get an abortion. This law has been described as a "new tactic to circumvent the judiciary" by Dyana Limon-Mercado, the executive director of Planned Parenthood Texas Votes. It is worth noting that abortion bans typically target providers, not patients, and Texas does not criminalize self-managed abortions.

The law doesn't provide exceptions for people who are victims of rape or incest and can be enforced as early as six weeks into a pregnancy, which is often before a woman even knows she is pregnant. This has raised concerns that the law will be used to intimidate and harass people who support women seeking abortions.

In one notable case, Marcus Silva sued his ex-wife's friends, alleging that they helped her obtain abortion pills. He sought over $1 million in damages, claiming that their actions were "criminal and murderous". However, Silva dropped the lawsuit, and it was widely seen as an attempt to intimidate and deter people from helping each other get abortions.

To challenge this aspect of Texas's abortion law, abortion rights activists and providers can continue to pursue legal options and block the implementation of the law. They can also raise awareness, protest, and provide support and resources for women seeking abortions, such as logistical and financial assistance. Additionally, national abortion rights groups can speak out and support defendants in these cases, as seen in the Marcus Silva lawsuit.

Texas' abortion law bans abortions after six weeks

Texas's abortion law, Senate Bill 8 (SB 8), bans abortions after six weeks of pregnancy, which is before most women even know they are pregnant. The law does not make exceptions for pregnancies resulting from rape or incest. While similar "heartbeat bills" across the US have been struck down by courts, Texas's new law is harder to challenge because it is not enforced by the state. Instead, the law allows private citizens to sue anyone who helps a woman get an abortion after a fetal heartbeat is detected.

The law, which came into effect on 1 September 2021, has been criticised for being difficult to challenge in court. Abortion providers and activists have found it hard to stop the law because there are no criminal penalties for violating the ban. The law has also been criticised for allowing almost anyone to enforce it with a civil suit, which could lead to a deluge of harassing lawsuits aimed at abortion providers and anyone who provides any kind of support to women seeking an abortion.

Despite the challenges, abortion rights activists are exploring all legal options to prevent the law from being implemented. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Texas and its partners are challenging the validity of the pre-Roe statutes in the courts. On 28 June 2022, a judge in Harris County sided with abortion providers and issued a temporary restraining order blocking any prosecutions under the pre-Roe statutes. However, Attorney General Ken Paxton sought emergency relief from the Texas Supreme Court, which granted it while maintaining the prohibition against prosecution by district attorneys.

Abortion funds, such as the National Network of Abortion Funds and the National Abortion Federation Hotline, are also providing logistical and financial support to people in Texas who need abortion care.

Texas' abortion law has no exceptions for rape or incest

Texas's abortion law, Senate Bill 8 (SB 8), bans abortion at all stages of pregnancy, without exceptions for rape or incest. This means that abortions are prohibited even in the early stages of pregnancy, when most women do not even know they are pregnant. The law allows private citizens to sue anyone who helps a woman get an abortion, with no criminal penalties for violating the ban.

The lack of exceptions for rape and incest in Texas's abortion law has been a cause for concern and criticism. It is important to note that, despite Texas Governor Greg Abbott's assurance that the state would work to eliminate rapists, data from the Texas Department of Public Safety shows that more than 14,000 rape crimes have been reported in the state since the law took effect. This highlights the impact of the law on victims of sexual assault, who may struggle to access timely and necessary abortion care.

The absence of exceptions for rape and incest in Texas's abortion law has also caused divisions among Republicans, with some finding it disagreeable. Additionally, it has been noted that the majority of sexual assaults are committed by someone known to the victim, which contradicts the idea that eliminating rapists from the streets will prevent all rape crimes.

The ACLU of Texas and its partners are challenging the validity of the pre-Roe statutes in the courts. On June 28, 2022, a judge in Harris County blocked any prosecutions under the pre-Roe statutes, but Attorney General Ken Paxton sought emergency relief from the Texas Supreme Court, which was granted. The ACLU continues to challenge the state's position in court, and the lawsuit is ongoing.

Frequently asked questions