Understanding Usury Laws: What Loans Are Affected?

Usury laws are interest rate laws that prevent lenders from charging unreasonably high rates on loans. These laws are enforced by individual states in the US rather than at a federal level, meaning that interest rate limitations vary across the country. Usury laws apply to different types of loans, including those with or without a written agreement from a non-bank institute, private student loans, payday loans, and any other types of contracts with non-bank institutes. Credit card lending may not be bound by usury laws, and credit card companies can charge interest rates that are allowed by the state where the company was incorporated, rather than the state of the borrower.

Usury laws and credit card interest rates

Usury laws are interest rate laws that prevent lenders from charging excessively high rates on loans. In the United States, these laws are enforced by individual states rather than at a federal level, meaning the interest rate limitations vary from one state to the next. While most states have usury laws, credit card companies and national banks are generally exempt from adhering to them. This is because federal court decisions and statutes allow these institutions to charge customers the interest rates permitted by the state in which the company or bank is headquartered, regardless of the state in which the customer resides.

For example, if you live in Arkansas, where the maximum interest rate is 17%, and your credit card company is headquartered in a state with a higher maximum interest rate, that company can charge you an amount above Arkansas' limit. If your credit card company is based in a state without usury laws, such as Maine, you have even less protection.

Similarly, nationally chartered banks can apply the highest interest rates allowed by the state in which the institution is incorporated. This is why many financial institutions are based in states like Delaware and South Dakota, which have very liberal or non-existent usury laws.

While there is no federally mandated maximum interest rate for credit cards, the Credit CARD Act does impose some restrictions on interest rates and provides more transparency for consumers. This legislation mandates that credit card companies notify cardholders in advance of any rate increases, giving a 45-day notice period before implementing changes. It also gives cardholders the right to cancel the credit card agreement without it being considered a "default" if a creditor proposes changes.

Some states have unique circumstances surrounding their usury laws. For instance, in Hawaii, the usury law sets the interest rate maximum at 10%, but this can be overridden by a written contract. In California, the maximum annual interest rate on consumer loans is 10%, but the law states that banks and similar institutions are exempt from this rule.

In addition, there are laws that protect military personnel and their dependents from high interest rates. The Military Lending Act caps credit card interest rates at 36% for active-duty military members and their dependents, while the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act caps interest rates on any credit card debt incurred by an active service member prior to entering the service at 6%.

Usury laws and private loans

Usury laws are interest rate laws designed to prevent lenders from charging excessively high rates on loans. In the United States, individual states are responsible for setting usury laws, and these laws are enforced at the state level.

Usury laws apply to private loans between individuals and private lending institutions, as well as loans made between individuals. For example, if you lend money to a friend and charge interest that is above the legal limit, the loan could be considered usurious.

The three basic elements of usury are:

• There must be a loan.
• There must be an agreement to repay the money.
• The agreement must include interest that is higher than the legal allowance.

The specific interest rate limitations vary from state to state. For example, New Jersey's general usury limit is 30% for individuals and 50% for corporations, while California's maximum interest rate for loans secured by real property is 10% per year.

It's important to note that usury laws do not apply to all types of loans. For instance, in New Jersey, usury laws do not apply to loans to corporations, limited liability companies, and limited liability partnerships. Additionally, credit card companies and nationally chartered banks can apply the highest interest rates allowed by the state where they are incorporated, which has led to many financial institutions choosing to incorporate in states with more lenient usury laws, such as Delaware and South Dakota.

Usury laws and payday loans

Usury laws are interest rate laws designed to prevent lenders from charging unreasonably high rates on loans. In the United States, individual states are responsible for setting these laws, which can vary significantly from state to state. While usury laws generally apply to a variety of loans, payday loans occupy a unique position in this landscape.

Payday loans, also known as cash advance loans, are short-term, unsecured loans intended to provide quick access to funds for borrowers facing financial emergencies. They are typically repaid in a lump sum on the borrower's next payday, often within a few weeks or a month. The small loan amounts, usually a few hundred dollars, are subject to state regulation, and states have traditionally capped interest rates for such loans at 24% to 48% annually.

However, the payday lending industry has evolved to circumvent these regulations. Many states have either deregulated small loan interest rate caps, failed to close loopholes exploited by the industry, or specifically exempted payday loans from usury laws. As a result, payday loans with triple-digit interest rates are legal in several states. This exemption from usury laws often occurs through the enactment of legislation that authorises payday loans based on holding the borrower's check or facilitating electronic payment from their bank account.

Despite these exemptions, some states have taken steps to protect their citizens from usurious payday lending. Eighteen states and the District of Columbia have effectively prohibited high-cost payday lending by setting usury rate caps, mostly at 36% APR, while some states have even lower caps. Nebraska, Hawaii, Illinois, New Mexico, and Minnesota are among the states that have recently capped payday loan rates at 36%.

In summary, while usury laws are intended to protect borrowers from excessive interest rates, the payday lending industry has found ways to operate outside these regulations in many states. This has led to a situation where payday loans with extremely high interest rates are legal in some states but strictly prohibited in others, creating a disparate impact on borrowers across the country.

Usury laws and state-by-state variations

Usury laws are interest rate laws designed to prevent lenders from charging unreasonably high rates on loans. These laws, which vary from state to state in the US, set a limit on how much interest can be charged on a variety of loans, protecting consumers from predatory lending and high-interest rates. While usury laws are enforced at the state level, credit card companies and nationally chartered banks can apply the interest rates allowed by the state in which they were incorporated.

State-by-State Variations

Each state sets its own maximum allowable interest rates for different types of loans and transactions. For example, California's general usury limit is 10%, while Florida's is 12%. Arkansas and Colorado allow for higher rates under certain circumstances, and some states, like Louisiana, use a sliding scale for interest rates.

Some states, such as New Jersey, have different usury limits for individuals and corporations. In New Jersey, the general usury limit is 30% for individuals and 50% for corporations. Pennsylvania considers interest above 25% as criminal usury.

The District of Columbia has a general usury limit of 24.01%, with a maximum rate of 25% for loans above $500,000 and a limit of 16% for loans below $3,000.

Washington State's usury law sets a maximum interest rate of 12% per year or 4% above the first auction quote on the Federal Reserve's 26-week treasury bills, whichever is higher.

While most states have been restricting interest rates for much of their history, some states, like Delaware and South Dakota, have relaxed their laws to attract financial institutions. Nevada, for instance, has no usury limits.

Exceptions and Complexities

While usury laws generally apply to loans between individuals or corporations, there are exceptions. For example, credit cards are often exempt from state usury laws because they are issued by national banks that are not subject to state jurisdiction. Pawn brokers and payday lenders also seem to avoid penalties under usury laws.

Some states allow higher interest rates for larger loan amounts or consumer revolving credit. There may also be specific regulations for agricultural loans, business loans, student loans, or loans for real estate.

Enforcement and Penalties

Usury laws are regulated and enforced by state legislatures and regulatory agencies. Lenders who violate usury laws may face penalties, including the forfeiture of all interest collected and, in some states, criminal prosecution. Borrowers who believe they have been charged excessive interest can consult legal representation and file complaints with their state's regulatory agencies.

Usury laws and their historical context

Usury laws have a long and complex history that dates back to ancient civilizations. These laws, which aim to prevent lenders from charging excessive interest rates, have been shaped by various religious, philosophical, and economic perspectives throughout the centuries.

Ancient Times to the Middle Ages

In ancient Mesopotamia, the Code of Hammurabi—one of the earliest known legal codes—contained provisions regulating interest rates. The laws limited interest rates depending on the type of loan, with rates ranging from 20% for grain loans to 33% for silver loans.

Ancient Greeks and Romans also had usury laws, although their perspectives differed. The Greeks viewed usury as morally wrong, while the Romans took a more pragmatic approach, considering excessive interest rates detrimental to economic stability. The Twelve Tables, a set of laws codified in ancient Rome, limited interest rates to 8.33% per annum.

During the Middle Ages, the Catholic Church played a significant role in shaping usury laws. Charging interest on loans was considered a sin, leading to the prohibition of usury in Christian Europe. However, as trade and commerce expanded, the Church's stance evolved, and it allowed interest to be charged within certain limits, known as "moderate usury."

Renaissance to Modern Times

The Renaissance period marked a shift in attitudes towards usury. The rise of capitalism and a more secular worldview led to interest rates being seen as a legitimate aspect of economic transactions. Usury laws became less stringent, allowing for greater flexibility in lending practices.

In the 19th and early 20th centuries, usury laws were gradually relaxed or abolished, particularly with the growing influence of free-market ideologies and the belief in the efficiency of market forces. This period saw the development of modern banking systems and complex financial instruments.

However, the Great Depression and subsequent economic crises led to a resurgence of interest in usury laws. Governments recognized the need for regulation to prevent predatory lending and ensure financial stability, resulting in the reintroduction of usury laws with specific caps on interest rates.

Usury Laws in the United States

The United States has a unique history with usury laws. During the Colonial era, usury laws were strict, with maximum interest rates and penalties for lenders who charged excessive rates. For example, in 18th-century Massachusetts, the maximum rate was 6%, and both principal and interest were forfeited if usury was proven.

Over time, these laws were eased and eventually repealed in many states. However, the United States never completely abandoned its system of usury laws. Today, usury laws in the US vary from state to state, with some states having no usury laws and others imposing strict limits on interest rates.

Frequently asked questions