Roman J. Israel: A Study In Legal Ethics

In the 2017 film 'Roman J. Israel, Esq.', the titular character, played by Denzel Washington, is a civil rights lawyer who finds himself in a series of tumultuous events that lead to a personal crisis. One of the central plot points of the film revolves around Roman's decision to anonymously collect a $100,000 reward for information leading to the capture of a fugitive, Carter CJ Johnson. This action is illegal and sets off a chain of consequences that form the crux of the narrative.

Context

Roman J. Israel, Esq. is a 2017 American legal drama film. The protagonist, played by Denzel Washington, is a civil rights lawyer who finds himself in a series of tumultuous events leading to a personal crisis.

Did Roman J. Israel break the law by collecting a reward for information?

In the 2017 legal drama film "Roman J. Israel, Esq.", the titular character, played by Denzel Washington, is a civil rights advocate and defence lawyer. The film follows Roman's life as he finds himself in a series of tumultuous events that lead to a personal crisis and the necessity for extreme action.

One of the main plot points of the film revolves around Roman's decision to anonymously collect a $100,000 reward for information leading to the arrest of a fugitive, Carter "CJ" Johnson. Roman obtains this information from one of his clients, Derrell Ellerbee, who is arrested for murder and willing to testify against Johnson. However, Roman's attempt to negotiate a plea deal for Ellerbee falls through, and he is denied the protective custody he requested in prison, ultimately leading to his murder.

After this incident, Roman becomes increasingly cynical and downcast. He resorts to using the information he received from Ellerbee to collect the reward for Johnson's location, which he uses to indulge in luxuries. This decision by Roman is illegal and unethical, as it involves disclosing privileged information obtained through his work as a lawyer. This act of collecting the reward money serves as a turning point in the film, leading to Roman's breakdown and realisation of the unlawfulness of his actions.

The consequences of Roman's decision are significant. He suffers a personal crisis as he recognises the unlawful and unethical nature of his actions. Additionally, Johnson, the fugitive whose location he disclosed, ends up in jail and threatens Roman with jail time or death. This leads to Roman's breakdown and attempts at reconciliation with those he wronged. Ultimately, Roman decides to turn himself in to the police, but he is killed by one of Johnson's henchmen before he can do so.

In conclusion, Roman J. Israel broke the law by collecting a reward for information as he disclosed privileged information obtained through his work as a lawyer. This decision had far-reaching consequences and contributed to the film's exploration of Roman's complex character and his struggle to uphold his ideals in a tumultuous legal landscape.

Did he break the law by mishandling a client's case?

In the film 'Roman J. Israel, Esq.', the titular character, played by Denzel Washington, is a lawyer who works behind the scenes at a small law firm in Los Angeles, preparing briefs and focusing on civil rights cases. When his partner, William Jackson, dies of a heart attack, the firm is left in debt and has to close. Jackson's former student, George Pierce, offers Roman a job at his large firm, which Roman initially declines. Eventually, Roman accepts the job but struggles to fit in at the new firm. He is assigned to handle clients, one of whom is Derrell Ellerbee, a young man arrested for murder. Ellerbee is willing to divulge the whereabouts of the actual shooter, Carter "CJ" Johnson, and testify against him.

However, Roman goes behind Pierce's back and attempts to negotiate a plea deal with the district attorney. When the prosecutor rejects his offer, Ellerbee is denied protective custody in prison and is subsequently murdered. Roman is berated by Pierce for mishandling Ellerbee's case. This, along with other factors, leads to Roman becoming cynical and using the information from Ellerbee to anonymously collect a $100,000 reward for Johnson's location, which is illegal.

While it is not explicitly stated which law Roman broke by mishandling Ellerbee's case, his actions had severe consequences, resulting in Ellerbee's death and his own breakdown as he recognises the unlawfulness of his actions. Roman's decision to anonymously collect the reward for Johnson's location, motivated by his growing cynicism and desire for luxury, can be seen as a breach of trust and an ethical violation, if not a direct violation of a specific law.

Did he break the law by anonymously collecting the reward?

In the film 'Roman J. Israel, Esq.', the titular character anonymously collects a $100,000 reward for information leading to the capture of a fugitive, Carter "CJ" Johnson. This action is presented as illegal and immoral within the context of the film, leading to Roman's breakdown and eventual decision to return the money.

While it is not explicitly stated what law Roman breaks, it is implied that his actions constitute a breach of client-attorney privilege and confidentiality. Roman obtains the information about Johnson's whereabouts from another client, Derrell Ellerbee, who is willing to divulge this information in exchange for a plea deal. Roman goes behind his colleague's back to negotiate this deal, which falls through, resulting in Ellerbee being denied the protective custody he requested and subsequently murdered.

Roman's use of privileged information to collect the reward is presented as a moral dilemma, with the character suffering a crisis of conscience and eventually renouncing his actions. This suggests that the film intends to portray Roman's actions as a violation of legal ethics and professional responsibility, rather than a specific criminal offence.

Roman's actions can be seen as a breach of the duty of confidentiality, which requires lawyers to protect and maintain the privacy of their clients' information. Additionally, his conduct may also implicate rules regarding conflicts of interest, as he uses information obtained from one client for his personal gain, potentially at the expense of the client's interests.

In conclusion, while the film does not specify the exact law broken by Roman J. Israel, his anonymous collection of the reward is portrayed as a violation of legal ethics and professional responsibility, particularly regarding client confidentiality and conflicts of interest.

Did he break the law by indulging in luxuries?

In the film 'Roman J. Israel, Esq.', the titular character indulges in luxuries after illegally using privileged information to collect a reward for turning in a fugitive. This marks a shift in Roman's behaviour, as he had previously eschewed such extravagances. However, it is important to note that Roman's indulgence in luxuries itself is not the illegal act, but rather a consequence of his prior illegal action.

Roman J. Israel, a lawyer played by Denzel Washington, works at a small law firm in Los Angeles, earning a modest salary of $500 a week. He is socially awkward, with peculiar fashion sense and outdated mannerisms, but possesses a brilliant legal mind and a strong commitment to social justice. After the death of his partner, William Jackson, Roman's firm faces closure due to debt. Jackson's former student, George Pierce, offers Roman a job at his large firm, which Roman initially rejects, believing Pierce to be a greedy lawyer.

Struggling to find another job, Roman eventually accepts Pierce's offer and joins the new firm. However, he struggles to fit in and clashes with his colleagues over ideological differences. One of his clients, Derrell Ellerbee, is arrested for murder and offers to divulge the whereabouts of the actual shooter, Carter Johnson, in exchange for protective custody. Roman goes behind Pierce's back and attempts to negotiate a plea deal, but his offer is rejected, and Ellerbee is denied protective custody. Unfortunately, Ellerbee is murdered in prison as a snitch.

Following this incident, Roman becomes disillusioned and cynical. He anonymously collects a $100,000 reward for Johnson's location using the privileged information he received from Ellerbee. This act of betraying his client's trust and breaking the law is what leads Roman to indulge in luxuries.

While Roman's specific actions in indulging in luxuries are not described in detail, it can be inferred that he spends a significant amount of the reward money on himself, possibly on expensive clothes, fine dining, or other extravagant purchases. This marks a notable change in his lifestyle, as he had previously led a frugal life, focused on his work and social activism.

In conclusion, while Roman J. Israel's indulgence in luxuries itself is not illegal, it is a direct result of his prior illegal action of betraying client confidentiality and collecting the reward. This sequence of events highlights the character's internal conflict and serves as a pivotal moment in the film's narrative.

Did he break the law by divulging privileged communications?

In the film 'Roman J. Israel, Esq.', the titular character, played by Denzel Washington, is a civil rights lawyer who finds himself in a series of tumultuous events that lead to a personal crisis. Roman is a brilliant but socially awkward lawyer who has spent years working behind the scenes in a small law firm in Los Angeles, earning $500 a week. He has strong convictions and a phenomenal memory but lacks social skills.

After the death of his partner, William Jackson, Roman is offered a job at a large firm by George Pierce, Jackson's former student. Roman initially rejects the offer, believing Pierce to be a greedy lawyer. However, after struggling to find another job, he reluctantly accepts.

At the new firm, Roman clashes with senior partner Jesse Salinas over a joke about battered women. He also attempts to negotiate a plea deal for a client, Derrell Ellerbee, who is arrested for murder. Ellerbee is willing to divulge the whereabouts of the actual shooter, Carter Johnson, and testify against him. However, Roman goes behind Pierce's back to negotiate the deal, and the prosecutor rejects his offer and hangs up on him. As a result, Ellerbee is denied protective custody in prison and is murdered as a snitch.

After being berated by Pierce for mishandling the case, Roman becomes cynical and uses the information he received from Ellerbee to anonymously collect a $100,000 reward for Johnson's location. He indulges in luxuries he previously avoided and eventually reconciles with Pierce and Maya, a woman he met during a job interview at a local activist network.

However, when Pierce brings Roman to meet a new client, it turns out to be Johnson, who accuses Roman of divulging privileged communications to collect the reward money. Roman suffers a breakdown as he recognizes the unlawfulness of his actions. He returns the reward money and tries to motivate Pierce and Maya to pursue their inner sense of justice. He then decides to turn himself in to the police but is shot and killed by one of Johnson's henchmen before he can do so.

In the context of the film's narrative, Roman J. Israel does break the law by divulging privileged communications. He uses information obtained from his client, Ellerbee, to anonymously collect a reward for Johnson's location, which is a breach of legal ethics and confidentiality. This action has severe consequences, including Ellerbee's murder and Roman's own breakdown and eventual death.

Frequently asked questions