The Law Code: Where Did It Apply?

Law codes, also known as legal codes, are a systematic collection of statutes that cover a complete system of laws or a particular area of law. They are written and compiled by ancient peoples and modern nations alike. The oldest evidence of a code of law was found in the ancient city of Ebla, in modern-day Syria, dating back to around 2400 BC. Since then, numerous civilisations and nations have developed and implemented their own legal codes, including ancient Mesopotamia, Rome, China, India, Japan, and modern countries like France, Germany, the United States, and more. These codes are an essential part of a country's legal system, providing a comprehensive framework for governing and adjudicating a wide range of matters, from criminal law to civil disputes.

Ancient Middle East

The ancient Middle East was home to several civilisations, each with its own set of laws and legal codes. The legal code was a common feature of the legal systems in this region, with many examples of cuneiform law.

The oldest evidence of a code of law in the ancient Middle East was found in Ebla, in modern-day Syria, and dates back to around 2400 BC. This was followed by the Sumerian Code of Ur-Nammu (c. 2100–2050 BC) and the Babylonian Code of Hammurabi (c. 1750 BC). The Code of Hammurabi is particularly notable as one of the earliest and most complete written legal codes. It was proclaimed by the Babylonian king Hammurabi, who reigned from 1792 to 1750 BC and united all of southern Mesopotamia. The code consists of 282 rules, establishing standards for commercial interactions and setting fines and punishments to meet the requirements of justice.

The various collections of cuneiform laws in the ancient Middle East shared certain features. For example, they often included a prologue and an epilogue in which the ruler emphasised the importance of the laws and commanded their observance. Additionally, the laws were secular and composed of dispositions fixed and codified by the temporal lord, even though they were written as if inspired by the gods.

Another important aspect of cuneiform law was its focus on individual cases and precedents rather than abstract, general formulas. This approach reflected the fact that legal customs were generally known and accepted, and the laws aimed to provide specific examples to guide future decisions.

The Sumerian civilisation, one of the oldest in the ancient Middle East, also had a well-developed legal system. While the Sumerian Code of Ur-Nammu is one of the oldest known legal codes, other Sumerian laws and legal documents have been discovered on cuneiform tablets, providing insights into their legal practices.

In addition to the Sumerians and Babylonians, other civilisations in the ancient Middle East, such as the Assyrians, Hittites, and Elamites, also developed their own legal codes, each adapted to their specific social and cultural contexts. These laws covered a range of topics, including personal property, family law, and commercial transactions, reflecting the diverse needs and concerns of these ancient societies.

Roman Empire

The Roman Empire's legal system, known as Roman law, was in place for over a thousand years and formed the basis for civil law, the most widely used legal system today. Roman law was the legal system of ancient Rome, spanning the Roman Republic and the Roman Empire, from the founding of the city in 753 BCE until the fall of the Western Empire in the 5th century CE. It continued to be used in the Eastern, or Byzantine, Empire until 1453.

The earliest laws of ancient Rome were based on centuries of custom and were handed down through generations, evolving alongside society. This customary law, or ius in Latin, was considered an integral part of early Roman culture as it applied only to Roman citizens and was thus known as ius civile, or civil law. During a period of social unrest, when legal decisions were thought to be arbitrary, there was a push to write down the law, leading to the creation of the Twelve Tables in 449 BCE.

The Twelve Tables were the foundation of Roman law and codified the centuries-old customary laws. They covered various areas, including civil law, public law, and religious law, and established rights and duties for Roman citizens. The tables were publicly displayed, providing a more balanced society where all Romans could understand the laws and their rights.

As the Roman Republic grew into an empire, its rulers faced the challenge of governing a diverse and far-flung population, including non-citizens to whom the ius civile did not apply. This led to the development of the ius gentium, or the "law of nations," which applied to all people based on common principles, and the ius naturale, or "natural law," based on principles shared by all living creatures.

Roman law continued to evolve and spread its influence even after the fall of the Western Roman Empire. It served as the legal system in most of Western Europe until the end of the 18th century and influenced the legal systems of former colonies, including Latin America and Ethiopia. English and Anglo-American common law also adopted Latin legal terminology from Roman law.

Ancient China

Confucianism

Confucianism held that the "five relationships" were the foundation of a well-ordered society. These were the relationships between:

• Ruler and subject
• Husband and wife
• Father and son
• Elder brother and younger brother
• Friend and friend

Confucians stressed that each individual should cultivate their inner virtue and demonstrate filial piety, which would enable them to maintain and strengthen these relationships and to properly fulfil the responsibilities that came with them. According to Confucianism, law should be viewed as a subsidiary tool, primarily to be used against determined wrongdoers who cannot be influenced by moral instruction.

Legalism

In contrast, Legalism advocated the utilisation of codified laws and harsh punishment to achieve social order. This was due to the Legalists' belief that all human beings are born evil and self-interested. Therefore, if left unrestrained, people would engage in selfish behaviour which would undoubtedly lead to social unrest. To cure this defect and force people to behave morally, the Legalists believed that clearly written laws, backed by state coercion, were necessary.

The Interaction of Confucianism and Legalism in Ancient China

The initial imperial Chinese legal code, that of the Qin dynasty (221–206 BCE), was crafted under the celebrated autocratic ruler Qin Shihuangdi, who was far more influenced by Legalism. The Qin sought to eradicate Confucianism but was unsuccessful. In fact, the Qin code retained elements of hierarchical treatment reminiscent of Confucianism. The Han dynasty (206 BCE–220 CE), which succeeded the Qin dynasty, filled the ranks of officialdom with Confucian scholars who revised the law to reconstruct and reinforce the five relationships.

The Han dynasty formally recognised four sources of law:

• Lü: codified laws
• Ling: the emperor's orders
• Ke: statutes inherited from previous dynasties
• Bi: precedents

The basic premise of Confucianism is the idea that human beings are fundamentally good. With this optimistic view of human potential, Confucius advocates for ruling through li – traditional customs, mores, and norms – which allow people to have a sense of shame and become humane. In contrast, codified laws require external compliance, and people may abide by the laws without fully understanding the reason for compliance.

The Great Qing Legal Code

The Great Qing Legal Code, also known as the Qing Code, was the legal code of the Qing empire (1644–1912). The code was based on the Ming legal code, the Great Ming Legal Code, which was kept largely intact. Compared to the Ming Code, the Qing Code contained 1,907 statutes across over 30 revisions between 1644 and 1912. The Qing Code was the last legal code of Imperial China and, by the end of the Qing dynasty, it had been the only legal code enforced in China for nearly 270 years.

The Great Qing Code comprises 436 articles divided into seven parts, further subdivided into chapters. The first part (Names and General Rules) is a General Part, which contains the general legal rules, principles, and concepts applied to the rest of the Code. The other six parts are named after the Six Ministries of government, and each part contains laws that are perceived as applicable to each ministry.

The Tang Code

The amalgamation of a Confucian worldview and a legal code was considered complete by the Tang Code (624 CE), which was regarded as a model of precision and clarity in terms of drafting and structure. Neo-Confucianism continued to be the state orthodoxy under the Song, Ming, and Qing dynasties. The Confucian foundations of the Tang Code were retained throughout the centuries, with some aspects strengthened.

Modern Europe

The law code, also known as a legal code, is a systematic collection of statutes that aims to comprehensively cover a legal system or a specific area of law. In modern Europe, the codification movement gained momentum following the emergence of nation-states after the Treaty of Westphalia.

One of the most influential codes in European history is the Napoleonic Code, also known as the French Civil Code, which was adopted in 1804. This code served as a model for the vast majority of modern civil codes worldwide. It was based on Roman law, particularly the Corpus Juris Civilis, which had become the foundation of many European countries' legal systems. The Austrian Civil Code (1812), the German Civil Code (1900), and the Swiss Civil Code are other examples of prominent national civil codes in Europe.

The 19th century witnessed a broader trend toward national codifications. The German Civil Code, enacted in 1896, the Swiss Civil Code (1907), and the Japanese Civil Code (1896) are notable examples of civil-law countries that followed in the footsteps of the Napoleonic Code.

In common-law countries, such as Great Britain, general law codes are less common. Instead, the law is largely based on previous judicial decisions. However, there have been attempts to establish uniform codes in specific areas of law, such as the Uniform Commercial Code in the United States.

Modern North America

In the United States, a code of law is a standing body of statute law on a particular area that is added to, subtracted from, or otherwise modified by individual legislative enactments. The United States Code contains the country's general and permanent laws, arranged into 54 broad titles according to subject matter. The organization of the Code was originally established by Congress in 1926, and 27 of the titles have since been restated and enacted into law by Congress as titles of the Code. The remaining titles are made up of sections from many acts of Congress that were either included in the original Code or subsequently added by editors. The Code includes the Constitution, several sets of Federal court rules, and certain Presidential documents, such as Executive orders, notices, and proclamations.

The US legal system is a common-law system, where codes are the exception rather than the rule. Codifications tend to be narrower, covering different types of procedure or penal and probate law. States adopt their own codes, and there have been attempts to establish uniform codes in various areas of law. The most comprehensive of these is the Uniform Commercial Code, which has been adopted by numerous jurisdictions in the country.

In the United States, civil law systems are found in Louisiana and Quebec. The Louisiana Civil Code Online is available to view online.

Frequently asked questions