Amdahl's Law: Parallel Computing's Friend Or Foe?

Amdahl's Law, named after computer scientist Gene Amdahl, is a principle in computer science that calculates the performance impact of optimising components of a program. It is often used in parallel computing to predict the theoretical maximum speedup when using multiple processors. The law states that the overall performance improvement gained by optimising a single part of a system is limited by the fraction of time that the improved part is used. In other words, the speedup of a parallel program is defined as the ratio of the rate at which work is done when a job is run on multiple processors to the rate at which it is done by just one.

Amdahl's Law and the Universal Scalability Law

Amdahl's Law, named after computer scientist Gene Amdahl, is a principle in computer science that calculates the performance impact of optimising components of a program. It determines the overall speedup based on the portion of code improved and the extent of the improvement. The law can be stated as:

> The overall performance improvement gained by optimising a single part of a system is limited by the fraction of time that the improved part is actually used.

In other words, Amdahl's Law predicts the speedup of a task's execution time when it is scaled to run on multiple processors. It states that the maximum speedup will be limited by the serial fraction of the task execution, as it will create resource contention.

The Universal Scalability Law (USL), developed by Neil J. Gunther, is an extension of Amdahl's Law. It accounts for the additional overhead due to interprocess communication and quantifies scalability based on parameters such as contention and coherency. USL is a black box approach to performance modelling and can be applied to any hardware, software, and different CPU architectures. It describes relative capacity in terms of concurrency, contention, and coherency:

> C(N) = N / [1 + α(N — 1) + βN (N — 1)]

Where C(N) is the relative capacity, α is the serial fraction between 0 and 1 due to resource contention, and β is the delay for data coherency or consistency.

Limitations of Amdahl's Law

Amdahl's Law is a principle in computer science that calculates the performance impact of optimising components of a program. It determines the overall speedup based on the portion of code improved and the extent of the improvement. It is important to note that Amdahl's Law has several limitations:

• Unrealistic Assumptions: Amdahl's Law assumes perfect parallelism and no overhead penalty. In reality, there are performance costs associated with creating and managing threads, as well as system-specific factors such as NUMA or processor workload.
• Limited Applicability: Amdahl's Law only applies when the problem size remains fixed. In practice, as more computing resources become available, they are often used for larger problems or datasets, which can affect the time spent in the parallelisable part of the code.
• Frustrating Results: The overall speedup achieved by Amdahl's Law can be much lower than expected. For example, speeding up 10% of the code by a factor of 10,000 may only result in an overall speedup of 11%. This means that the return on investment for optimising certain parts of the code may be minimal.
• Sequential Bottlenecks: Amdahl's Law highlights the importance of optimising the sequential parts of the code that cannot be parallelised. Even with an infinite number of processors, the speedup is limited by the fraction of the code that cannot be parallelised.
• Overhead Costs: As the number of processors increases, the overhead costs of managing parallel tasks can become significant, reducing the overall speedup.
• Diminishing Returns: Amdahl's Law demonstrates the law of diminishing returns when adding more processors to a machine. Each additional processor adds less usable power than the previous one, and the speedup ratio diminishes as the total throughput approaches its limit.
• Other Bottlenecks: Amdahl's Law does not account for other potential bottlenecks, such as memory bandwidth and I/O bandwidth. If these resources do not scale with the number of processors, adding more processors may result in even lower returns.
• Heterogeneous Computing: Amdahl's Law implies that to speed up applications with both serial and parallel portions, heterogeneous computing techniques are required. This is because the speedup is limited by the fraction of the code that cannot be parallelised.
• Strong Scaling: Amdahl's Law assumes strong scaling, meaning that the difficulty of the problem is unaffected by the number of processors. In reality, weak scaling is more common, where additional processors are used to tackle bigger and more complex problems, rather than reducing the time to solve the problem.

Despite these limitations, Amdahl's Law is still a valuable tool for

Amdahl's Law and parallel speedup

Amdahl's Law, named after computer scientist Gene Amdahl, is a formula that predicts the potential speed increase in completing a task with improved system resources while keeping the workload constant. It is often used in parallel computing to predict the theoretical speedup when using multiple processors.

The law can be stated as:

> The overall performance improvement gained by optimizing a single part of a system is limited by the fraction of time that the improved part is actually used.

In other words, the maximum improvement in speed will always be limited by the most significant bottleneck in a system. This bottleneck is the portion of the system or program that takes the longest to complete.

The base formula for Amdahl's Law is:

> S = 1 / (1 - p + p/s)

Where:

• S is the speedup of a process
• P is the proportion of a program that can be made parallel
• S is the speedup factor of the parallel portion

This formula states that the maximum improvement in speed of a process is limited by the proportion of the program that can be made parallel.

Amdahl's Law is popular among developers because it offers a simple and efficient way to determine the maximum potential for improving system performance. By identifying the bottleneck in a program or system, developers can focus their efforts on optimising that particular component instead of wasting time working on parts that will have minimal returns.

However, Amdahl's Law does not apply to situations where a problem size or workload can increase. This is because the formula assumes that the workload and problem size are fixed.

Examples of Amdahl's Law in Action

Teammate Collaboration

Your company has scheduled a meeting with three team members first thing in the morning. Each team member needs to get themselves to the office, but they can't start the meeting until everyone has arrived. Two of the sales members drive themselves into the office, while the third teammate rides their bicycle. According to Amdahl's Law, if the team wants to start their meetings earlier, then they need to focus on the performance of the cyclist. Even if one of the drivers drives faster than usual, there's still no way to get around the fact that they have to wait for the bicyclist who is the bottleneck in this situation.

Website Performance

An online store has just released a new product and is expecting a huge surge in web traffic. To handle the increased demand, they decide to add more servers to their system. While additional servers can help them handle the increased traffic, they are limited by how quickly each page is served — that will be the bottleneck of the system. According to Amdahl's Law, they need to focus on optimising their webpages rather than simply adding more servers to help with the surge in traffic.

Amdahl's Law in modern programming

Amdahl's Law, named after computer scientist Gene Amdahl, is a principle in computer science that calculates the performance impact of optimising components of a program. It is often used in parallel computing to predict the theoretical speedup when using multiple processors.

The Formula

Amdahl's Law can be formulated as:

> "The overall performance improvement gained by optimising a single part of a system is limited by the fraction of time that the improved part is actually used."

Mathematically, this can be expressed as:

> S = 1 / (1 - P + (P / N))

Where:

• S is the speedup of the system
• P is the proportion of the system that can be improved
• N is the number of processors in the system

Applications in Modern Programming

Amdahl's Law has several important applications in modern programming:

• Determining speedup: The law can be used to determine the maximum speedup that can be achieved by parallelising a program. This can help guide hardware and software design decisions.
• Identifying non-parallelisable portions: Amdahl's Law helps identify sections of a program that are not easily parallelised. This information can be used to optimise those portions of the code.
• Trade-offs between parallelisation and optimisation: The law provides a framework for understanding the trade-offs between parallelisation and other forms of optimisation, such as code optimisation and algorithmic improvements.
• Estimating speedup: By applying Amdahl's Law, programmers can quickly estimate the speedup factor that can be achieved by devoting more hardware to a specific portion of a computation.
• Optimisation of specific code portions: Conversely, the law can also be used to identify which sections of a program can be profitably optimised. For example, a code portion dominated by sequential operations may only provide a mediocre return on investment if parallelised.
• Understanding limitations: Amdahl's Law helps programmers understand the limitations of parallelisation. Running code in parallel on multiple processors rarely provides a linear speed increase, and scaling problems can occur with an increasing number of parallel execution threads.

Limitations of Amdahl's Law

Amdahl's Law has some limitations and assumptions that may not hold true in practice:

• Fixed non-parallelisable portion: The law assumes that the portion of the program that cannot be parallelised is fixed. However, in reality, code optimisation may reduce the size of this portion, making Amdahl's Law less accurate.
• Homogeneous processors: It assumes that all processors have the same performance characteristics, which may not be the case in heterogeneous computing environments.
• Communication overhead: The law does not account for communication overhead and load balancing, which can impact the actual speedup achieved in practice.
• Problem size: Amdahl's Law applies only when the problem size is fixed. In practice, as more computing resources become available, they are often used for larger problems, and the time spent on the parallelisable part may grow faster than the serial work. In such cases, Gustafson's Law provides a more realistic assessment of parallel performance.

The future of Amdahl's Law

Amdahl's Law, a principle in computer science, has been used by computer scientists for over 55 years and continues to be relevant in the modern day. However, it is important to note that Amdahl's Law has its limitations and does not account for all factors that may impact the speed of a program.

Amdahl's Law assumes a fixed problem size and does not account for the impact of increasing the number of processors on the problem size. In practice, as more computing resources become available, they are often used for larger problems (larger datasets). Therefore, the time spent on the parallelizable part of a task may increase much faster than the time spent on the serial work. As a result, Amdahl's Law may not accurately predict the speedup in such cases.

To address this limitation, Gustafson's Law provides a modified perspective. It assumes that the amount of work that can be parallelized grows linearly with the number of processors, which is more realistic for many scenarios. However, Gustafson's Law can be overly optimistic and may not account for real-world complexities such as diminishing returns due to parallel processing complexities and communication overhead.

In the future, the applicability of Amdahl's Law may become more limited as computing technology advances. To fully utilize the potential of parallel computing, heterogeneous computing techniques may be required to speed up applications with both serial and parallel portions. Additionally, novel speedup and energy consumption models based on a more general representation of heterogeneity are being developed to support a wide range of heterogeneous many-core architectures. These models aim to predict system power efficiency and performance ranges and facilitate research and development at the hardware and system software levels.

Furthermore, as problem sizes increase, the “inherently serial” fraction of a program may decrease, as stated by Gustafson's Law. This means that the limitations imposed by Amdahl's Law may become less significant, and greater speedups may be achievable.

In conclusion, while Amdahl's Law has been a crucial principle in computer science for over five decades, its applicability may evolve as computing technology advances. The future of Amdahl's Law lies in considering its limitations and incorporating heterogeneous computing techniques to address the challenges of parallel computing in modern and future systems.

Frequently asked questions