Abortion Laws: 1800S Restrictions And Their Origins

Abortion laws in the 1800s were created in response to a variety of factors, including the efforts of male doctors to criminalize the procedure and take control of reproductive healthcare, shifting social attitudes, and the influence of the Catholic Church and other religious groups. During this time, abortion was a common practice, with an estimated one in five women in the 19th century having had an abortion. However, the increasing professionalization of medicine and the formation of the American Medical Association (AMA) in 1847 led to a campaign to outlaw abortion and restrict women's access to reproductive choices. This was part of a broader antifeminist backlash against the growing movements for women's suffrage, voluntary motherhood, and other women's rights. Additionally, falling birth rates and concerns about race suicide among whites contributed to the push for abortion criminalization. As a result of these factors, by the end of the 19th century, abortion laws had been enacted in most states, and the practice was driven underground, often with dangerous consequences for women.

The role of the American Medical Association (AMA)

In the 1800s, male physicians took over women's established sources of medical care and knowledge, causing friction between women and their health matters and the rising medical profession. This conflict still exists today.

In 1847, doctors formed the American Medical Association (AMA). It became a male-dominated authority on medical practices, scrutinising reproductive healthcare workers like midwives and nurses. The obstetric services they provided were phased out.

AMA members believed they should have the power to decide when an abortion could be legally performed. However, the AMA was composed of physicians who lacked expertise in pregnancy and reproductive health. They launched a criminalisation campaign against abortion and female abortion providers. State legislatures moved to ban abortion.

The formation of the AMA and its subsequent campaign against abortion and female abortion providers resulted in the regulation of women and their sexuality. The new political climate concerning abortion meant that women's reproductive decisions were blamed for the complications of abortion.

The social status of women

Women's education was limited to practical training for their domestic roles, such as home management, laundry, cookery, piano classes, and needlework. They had little to no economic freedom and extremely limited control over personal property after marriage. They were rarely granted legal custody of their children in cases of divorce, and were barred from institutions of higher education.

The idea of male superiority and ownership of women was prevalent, and women were often viewed as the "second sex". They were dependent on men and lacked any unique identity or entity of their own. Single, married, or widowed, women were imprisoned in a state of powerlessness.

In the context of abortion, the male-dominated medical profession sought to take authority from female-dominated professions, including midwives, who provided reproductive care. The formation of the American Medical Association (AMA) in 1847 gave male physicians the power to decide when an abortion could be legally performed, and they launched a criminalization campaign against abortion and female abortion providers. This resulted in the criminalization of abortion in the late 1800s, which restricted women's reproductive freedom and pushed them towards unsafe, illegal abortion services.

The criminalization of abortion providers

The criminalization of abortion in the 1800s was largely driven by physicians who wanted to take authority over reproductive healthcare from female-dominated professions such as midwifery. In the US, the formation of the American Medical Association (AMA) in 1847 played a key role in this process. The AMA was a male-dominated organization that sought to discredit and replace female healthcare providers such as midwives and nurses who had traditionally provided reproductive care. AMA members lacked expertise in pregnancy and reproductive health but believed they should have the power to decide when abortions could be legally performed. They launched a full-fledged criminalization campaign against abortion and female abortion providers, successfully lobbying state legislatures to ban the procedure.

This campaign was also driven by a desire to standardize the medical profession and eliminate competition from untrained or informally trained abortion providers, who were often cheaper and more accessible to women. Additionally, physicians' views on abortion were shaped by their understanding of the human body as a place of equilibrium. They believed that any disruption, such as a cessation of a woman's menstrual period due to pregnancy, needed to be remedied swiftly, and this included ending the pregnancy.

The criminalization of abortion was also influenced by broader social and cultural factors. Falling birth rates and concerns about losing cultural dominance due to increased immigration contributed to a growing opposition to abortion. Religious groups, such as the Catholic Church, also played a role in advocating for abortion bans.

By the end of the 19th century, nearly every state in the US had passed laws restricting or banning abortion. These laws stigmatized abortion and pushed the practice underground, leading to unsafe procedures and a high death toll among women. The criminalization of abortion in the 1800s set the stage for a "century of criminalization" that would only be ended by the Roe v. Wade ruling in 1973, which established the legal right to access abortion nationwide.

The influence of religion

In the 1800s, abortion was generally believed to be acceptable until "quickening", or the first detection of foetal movement, which usually occurs after four months of pregnancy. This belief was held by most religious groups, and no major religion took an absolute stance against abortion. However, the Catholic Church and some Evangelical Christians considered life to begin at conception and equated abortion with murder. These religious groups began to lobby state governments to restrict abortion, and by 1910, abortion was banned nationwide in the US.

The American Medical Association (AMA), formed in 1847, also played a role in the criminalization of abortion. The AMA was male-dominated and lacked expertise in pregnancy and reproductive health. Its members believed they should have the authority to decide when abortions could be legally performed and launched a criminalization campaign against abortion. This campaign was supported by religious doctors who were concerned about the morality and safety of abortion.

It is important to note that the religious debate around abortion was nuanced and complex, and religious support for abortion access has also been documented throughout history. For instance, in the 1960s and 1970s, some Christian denominations, such as the United Church of Christ, American Baptist Convention, and the Southern Baptist Convention, issued statements in support of legal abortion under certain circumstances. Additionally, faith-based funds have helped pay for reproductive care, and clergy have blessed health clinics and hosted abortion support groups.

In summary, while religion played a significant role in shaping abortion laws in the 1800s, the influence of specific religious groups and the nuances within their beliefs should be considered. The criminalization of abortion resulted from a complex interplay of religious, social, and political factors, and the debate around abortion within religious circles continues to evolve.

The impact on women's reproductive rights

Abortion laws in the 1800s had a significant impact on women's reproductive rights, both at the time and in the subsequent decades.

Prior to the 1800s, abortion was a regular part of life for women in the US. Common law allowed abortions to be performed before "quickening", an old-fashioned term for when foetal movement is first detected, usually around four months into a pregnancy. Abortion methods during this time were often herbal or medicinal, as surgical procedures were rare. Reproductive care, including abortions, was provided by skilled midwives, nurses, and other unlicensed women's healthcare providers.

In the mid-1800s, abortion laws began to be introduced in the US, with a number of states passing anti-abortion legislation in the 1860s. These laws were often ambiguous and challenging to enforce, but they marked a shift towards restricting women's reproductive rights. This shift was driven by a coalition of male doctors, supported by the Catholic Church and others who sought to control women's bodies. The formation of the American Medical Association (AMA) in 1847 played a significant role in this shift, as AMA members believed they should have the authority to decide when abortions could be legally performed. The AMA launched a criminalisation campaign against abortion, and by 1880, all states had laws restricting abortion, with only limited exceptions.

As abortion became criminalised, it also became stigmatised, and women were increasingly pushed towards illegal and unsafe abortion services. By 1910, abortion was banned nationwide, and nearly 2,700 women died from unsafe abortions in 1930 alone. The criminalisation of abortion also disproportionately impacted women of colour and those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, as they often lacked the means to access safe abortions or travel to skirt the law.

It wasn't until the 1960s and 1970s that abortion law reform gained momentum, with activists, healthcare providers, and legal professionals advocating for change. In 1973, the landmark Roe v. Wade case established the legal right to access abortion nationwide, reaffirming women's reproductive rights and ending the "century of criminalisation".

Frequently asked questions